![]() |
|
Horizon Parking PCN - Printable Version +- Private Parking Ticket Legal Advice (PPTLA) (https://pptla.uk) +-- Forum: Legal advice forum (https://pptla.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Parking Charge Notices forum (https://pptla.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Horizon Parking PCN (/showthread.php?tid=121) |
RE: Horizon Parking PCN - Tortfeasor - 10-01-2026 Hi @b789 Thank you once again for your help. You would get my nomination to be on the New Year Honours list! I chuckled a lot when skim-reading Horizon’s POPLA response before I shared it. The thing that gave me the biggest chuckle was discovering these supposed provided “case records” in Schedule C showing the NtK was, “correctly issued,” weren’t included. I am even more convinced now that the original NtK didn’t enter the postal system. I forgot to mention to you, when I came home about 2 weeks ago, I received what I’d call a “final demand for payment” letter from Horizon with a September issue date. I was still within the POPLA appeal window, which I thought was reflective of Horizon’s practices generally. However, I’ve received that keeper reminder letter in July and the final demand for payment letter in September. Logic tells me if the NtK had actually entered the postal system in May, I’d have also received it. I had a feeling the matter of the 2 different issue dates given in Horizon’s response was worth mentioning. I did a double-take when I first read references to an issue date of 28 May, as everything I’d read from Horizon prior to its POPLA response had maintained it had issued the charge on 27 May. When I received Horizon’s reply to my appeal on July 31st, which harped on about me providing evidence the driver was a customer, I knew I’d likely been sent some template. I completely ignored it at the time as I knew I’d not made representations about, “customer status.” I didn’t think Horizon would try and resurrect it again though. I really like how you phrased the point about Horizon trying to convert its own invented premise about claiming customer status into a submission I had made! It also didn’t escape me about how ill-thought out it was for Horizon to criticise my provided photos from 3 months after the event but then relying on ones it has from 20 months beforehand. Whoever wrote Horizon’s response needs to develop a better ability to paraphrase and quote too. I noted there is a reference to the appellant stating the car park entrance sign is near a tree. Incorrect preposition. I stated the sign was underneath a tree and ever since I discovered this fact, it has been central to my point about the lack of visibility that results because of it, especially at night. Near a tree would be one thing, but underneath a tree - and as you saw from the photos and footage it’s not some little garden shrub - it causes that sign to be enshadowed. I found the dismissiveness in Horizon’s response about my points about the entrance sign a very poor showing. It is the largest of all their signs at that car park. Its response reads like it’s downplaying the sign. I also didn’t just focus on that one sign either despite Horizon saying I did. Clearly Horizon didn’t want to bother to comment about that other sign within the car park, which is nearest to the actual store entrance and in the parent and child bays, and is outshone by the glare from the lighting inside the shop at night I will keep you updated. Thank you! RE: Horizon Parking PCN - b789 - 10-02-2026 You're very welcome, and thank you for the kind words. The September demand is worth retaining. It does not itself prove that the original NtK was never posted, but it strengthens the credibility of your evidence: Horizon successfully delivered both its July reminder and September demand, yet the supposedly crucial May NtK was the one document that never arrived. More importantly, Horizon has still produced no mailing record or audit trail showing that it entered the postal system. The conflicting dates and missing "case records" are particularly damaging because those are matters entirely within Horizon's own records. It cannot reasonably expect you to explain discrepancies that it created and has failed to address. Its treatment of the signage evidence is equally poor. "Near a tree" plainly misrepresents the point that the entrance sign is underneath a substantial tree and consequently obscured and unlit at night. Horizon has also ignored the internal sign affected by glare and the conflicting YourParkingSpace signs, while criticising your evidence as three months later and relying upon its own photographs from twenty months earlier. Ultimately, Horizon's response appears to avoid the evidence it cannot satisfactorily answer. We must now see whether the POPLA assessor properly engages with those omissions. Please do keep us updated. RE: Horizon Parking PCN - Tortfeasor - 11-16-2026 Hi @b789 and everyone, I’ve received my decision from POPLA today regarding the appeal. Decision: Unsuccessful. I am not perturbed by this, but I am finding the absurdity of it rather tedious. It looks to me the assessor has just accepted the Operator’s evidence without even really addressing the points I raised. The most laughable bits for me are: - how they don’t deal with the fact there is evidence that undermines the NtK was in fact delivered within the statutory window that it should have been, if Horizon is relying on PoFa. They’ve missed the point made here. POPLA states I’ve said I received the NtK claimed to be issued on 28 May in July. No! I clearly stated I’d only received a reminder. I never received the NtK! - how they’ve “addressed” the fact there’s conflicting Your Parking Space signage in the car park; and - the points about the parking event occurring at night. I was the only party to provide any evidence to POPLA showing signage at night. It’s preposterous that POPLA has said Horizon’s evidence shows the signs are illuminated at night. You can clearly see all of the photos Horizon provided were taken in the morning! That can’t possibly show signage illuminated at night. My evidence clearly showed an entrance sign at night that wasn’t illuminated, underneath a large tree, and exacerbated by the dark background of the sign, which made it illegible even with full beam headlights on it, while I was stationary at the roundabout in front of said sign! The fact POPLA quotes the Code of Practice requiring signs to be legible in all lighting conditions and in the case of entrance signs taking into account the speed of vehicles approaching the car park beggars belief. Regarding how they’ve “addressed” the Your Parking Space conflicting signage, it’s just a nonsense. Those conflicting signs state, “parking for more than 3 hours,” and the parking event was just over 1 hour in duration based on Horizon’s timestamps, not including a grace or consideration period. How the driver would have been able to take up the Your Parking Space offer and comply with Horizon’s terms then is anyone’s guess! So, you can park for more than 3 hours if you book via Your Parking Space but you are and aren’t allowed to park between 1-3 hours when the shop is still open after 10pm. Right… that’s about as clear as my mug of black coffee! I’ve copied the response from the POPLA portal: The operator has issued the Parking Charge Notice (PCN) due to exceeding the maximum stay period. Assessor summary of your case The appellant has provided a detailed account surrounding the parking event in question. For the purpose of my report, I have summarised the grounds raised into the points below. • Horizon has not established keeper liability under Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012. • Horizon's Subject Access Request response materially undermines the reliability of its records. • Horizon has not proved that it had landowner authority. • Conflicting YourParkingSpace signs prevent Horizon from establishing any clear and unambiguous contractual terms. • The signage provided by Horizon is non-contemporaneous. • The ANPR timestamps do not establish the alleged period of parking, including the time take to park and leave the site. • Horizon has not proved that the contractual terms were adequately displayed at night. The appellant has provided 1. Copy of their appeal. 2. Copy of their SAR email response. 3. Photograph of the ‘Your Parking Space Signage’ 4. Photograph of the entrance signage. 5. Photograph of the on site hours restrictions sign. 6. Photo of their PCN. 7. 2 Screenshots from the Your Parking Space website indicating 24hrs parking is available. 8. Video of their dashcam footage. After reviewing the operator’s evidence, the appellant reiterates much of concerns from their initial appeal. All of the above has been considered in making my determination. Assessor supporting rational for decision The appellant has identified as the keeper of the vehicle on the day of the parking event. The operator has provided evidence to demonstrate it has complied with the Protection of Freedoms Act (PoFA. 2012). The parking event occurred on 22 May and the notice to keeper was issued on 28 May, within the 14 day window. I note the appellant’s comments that it was not received until 1 July, however the notice is deemed delivered 2-3 days after its issue date. Without evidence to the contrary, I am considering the appellant ’s liability for the PCN, as the keeper. I note the appellant’s comments with regard to the Subject Access Request, however this is an issue for the appellant to take up directly with Horizon Parking. POPLA’s role is to assess the if the operator has issued the charge in accordance with the conditions of the contract. Based on the evidence provided to POPLA, I am satisfied it did. When assessing an appeal POPLA considers if the operator has issued the parking charge notice correctly and if the driver has complied with the terms and conditions for the use of the car park. The operator has provided photographic evidence of the signage in place in the car park, which detail the terms and conditions of parking. The signs advise ‘3 Hours Maximum Stay between 6am-10pm – 1 Hour Maximum Stay between 10pm-12am – 15 Minutes Maximum Stay between 12am-6am daily & 6pm012am Sunday’ and refers users to see signage in the car park for terms and conditions. Additional signage provides details of the tariffs that apply based on duration of stay and the terms and conditions that apply when parking on the site. This repeats the maximum stay period. For motorists who are parking for more than 3 hours, they can purchase parking with the YourParkingSpace using the app at location ID 11276. The motorist is also advised that failure to comply with the terms and conditions will result in a PCN being issued for £100. The operator has provided photographs of the signage and a site map to demonstrate that the signs were clearly visible and located throughout the car park. The operator has also provided ANPR photographs showing the appellant entered the site at 22:45:17 and left at 23:57:10, for a total stay of 1hr 11m 53s. Section 3.1.1 of the Single Code of Practice states that there must be an entrance sign displayed and maintained at the entrance to the site, to inform drivers whether parking is permitted subject to terms and conditions or prohibited. Section 3.1.2 of the Code contains the principles the entrance sign must display, including whether public parking is available and if a payment is required. Its design must also comply with the standard format as described in Annex A. The entrance sign must take into account the speed of vehicles approaching the car park. In this case the parking operator’s evidence shows clear entrance signage which tells motorists the car park is privately owned land and that there are terms and conditions attached to the car park. Section 3.1.3 of the Single Code of Practice contains the requirements for signs displaying the terms and conditions. The signs must be placed throughout the site, so that drivers have the opportunity to read them when parking or leaving their vehicle. The terms and conditions must be clear and unambiguous, using a font and contrast that is conspicuous and legible. Section 3.1.6 of the Single Code of Practice states that signs should be conspicuous and legible in all lighting conditions, including during dusk and in the dark if the land is accessible at those times. The signs must be installed at a height that takes into account where the signs will be viewed from, and whether vehicle headlights will illuminate the signs in the dark. In this case the operator's evidence demonstrates the signage complies with the code and clearly communicated the terms and conditions to the appellant and that a valid parking contract could be formed. Furthermore, based on all the evidence provided, including the video and photographs provided by the appellant, I am satisfied the area contained lighting poles to illuminate the signage on site. I note the signage is not contemporaneous. However, the operator is not required to provide images of the signage taken on the exact date of the parking event. Rather, it must demonstrate that adequate signage was in place at the site and that the terms and conditions were clearly displayed. I am satisfied that the operator has provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate the parking terms that were in force at the time. The site operates ANPR cameras, which capture vehicles entering and exiting the site to calculate the time a vehicle has remained in the car park and this will be used for the car park management and enforcement. This data captured is then compared with the online transaction record, and if a vehicle has remained on the site for longer than authorised, or without payment located for the vehicle registration, a parking breach of the terms is identified. Section 5.1 of the Single Code of Practice states that parking operators must allow a consideration period of appropriate duration, subject to the requirements set out in Annex B to allow a driver time to decide whether or not to park. This is typically 5-10 minutes depending on the site. However, the consideration period is not an additional period of free parking. It is to allow the user time to leave the car park if they do not wish to accept the terms for parking on the site. If a user decides to stay and use the parking facility, the consideration period becomes part of the total time on site and the user must then comply with the terms and conditions of the car park. Section 5.2 of the Single Code of Practice also requires a parking operator to allow a grace period of 10 minutes in addition to the parking period. The Code advises that grace periods do not apply other than where a driver has parked in compliance with the terms and conditions of the area. The grace period is not a period of free parking. In this case, I can see that the appellant exceeded the grace period by 1 minute and 53 seconds. While I appreciate that this is only a small amount of time, the grace period provided by the Code has a defined limit and must be applied consistently to all motorists. If an operator were expected to disregard every overstay that exceeded the grace period by only a short time, there would be no clear point at which enforcement could fairly and consistently begin. The appellant has stated that Conflicting YourParkingSpace signs prevent Horizon from establishing any clear and unambiguous contractual terms. However, I find no conflict with the YourParkingSpace signs. Should a motorist wish to stay longer than the maximum permitted periods allowed at the car park, they can purchase parking via YourParkingSpace. As the appellant has not provided any evidence parking beyond the prescribed maximum stay periods was purchased, they were not entitled to exceed the 1 hour maximum stay period that applied when they used the car park. The appellant has stated the operator has not demonstrated that it has the necessary authority from the landowner to issue and enforce parking charges at this location. Section 14.1 of the Code states that where controlled land is being managed on behalf of a landowner, written confirmation must be obtained before a parking charge can be issued. The evidence provided in relation to this appeal meets the criteria POPLA requires, and therefore I am satisfied that the operator has sufficient authority at the site on the date of the parking event. Whenever a motorist uses a private parking facility, it is their responsibility to ensure they comply with the terms of the site being used. This not exceeding the maximum stay period allowed unless they have purchased additional time via YourParkingSpace. POPLA’s role is to assess if the operator has issued the charge in accordance with the conditions of the contract. As the terms and conditions of the car park have not been met, I conclude that the operator has issued the parking charge correctly, and the appeal is refused. So, what do I do next? Thanks, as always, for your help. RE: Horizon Parking PCN - b789 - 11-16-2026 Hi @Tortfeasor. You are right to be unimpressed. The assessor has not merely reached conclusions with which we disagree; they have materially misstated your evidence and avoided the central legal issue. You never said that the NtK dated 28 May was received on 1 July. Your evidence was that no original NtK was ever received and that the document received in July was a reminder. The assessor has therefore based the keeper-liability finding upon something you did not say. The assessor has then treated the date printed on Horizon’s newly produced NtK as proof that it was posted and deemed delivered. That completely misses the point. Paragraph 9(6) of Schedule 4 presumes delivery on the second working day after posting; it does not presume that posting occurred merely because an operator later produces a document bearing an issue date. Horizon was put to strict proof of posting and supplied none of the “case records” it claimed confirmed issue. The signage reasoning is equally unsatisfactory. Horizon supplied daylight photographs, yet the assessor somehow concluded that its evidence demonstrated adequate illumination at night. The existence of lighting columns somewhere within the car park does not prove that the entrance sign underneath the tree, or the terms sign affected by glare from the store, was illuminated or legible. Your nighttime photographs and video showed precisely the opposite. The assessor has also invented an explanation for the YourParkingSpace signs which Horizon itself never properly evidenced. Saying that motorists may purchase additional time does not resolve how a sign offering “parking for more than 3 hours” interacts with Horizon’s one-hour restriction, particularly where no clear information explains when or how one scheme overrides the other. I wouldn’t bother making a formal complaint to POPLA as they are a waste of time, and, as you have seen, hopelessly inept with their understanding of the law. You should proceed with the ICO complaint concerning Horizon’s defective SAR response. Beyond that, the choice is whether to pay or stand your ground. If you are prepared to defend the matter, POPLA’s decision is not binding upon you and does not establish legal liability. Horizon would still have to bring a County Court claim and prove its case before a judge. Keep every letter, the complete POPLA submissions and evidence packs, the decision, your nighttime photographs and videos, and the YourParkingSpace material. Debt-recovery letters can be filed in the bin and safely ignored. Do not ignore a formal Letter of Claim or County Court claim. If either arrives, return here immediately. A defended claim does not damage your credit record; even if Horizon ultimately obtained judgment, a CCJ would not remain registered if the judgment were paid in full within one calendar month. On the evidence presently available, I would not regard this deeply flawed POPLA decision as any reason to abandon the matter. RE: Horizon Parking PCN - Tortfeasor - 11-16-2026 Thank you so much, @b789. You’d managed my expectations about how things can go with POPLA very well. I’m unsurprised in some respects how they’ve dealt with this. I have seen how other people have described POPLA elsewhere and I can understand why! It really does seem to me this is another case where the assessor just accepted the operator’s explanation and “evidence” at face value. I put evidence in inverted commas due to the lack of it, particularly those missing case records we’d drawn to POPLA’s attention that Horizon stated it supplied in its response showing the NtK being correctly delivered. I think a fair-minded person would have looked at that and the lack of “nighttime conditions” evidence from Horizon to rebut what I’d submitted and arrived at a different conclusion. POPLA’s explanation of the conflict with the Your Parking Space signs/terms was far too favourable to Horizon, which hadn’t even bothered to comment about it. I hope my faith isn’t misplaced, but I would hope a court would take a different view on this aspect, particularly with the Consumer Rights Act s.69. I happened to drive to the “scene of the crime” after visiting a relative in hospital the other night. Even though that large tree has shed its leaves now, you still can’t see the words on that entrance sign at night with full beam headlights flashing on it. No new “lighting poles” near it either. The Your Parking Space signs are still up in the car park too. I did make a complaint to the ICO and have had a holding response. It hadn’t been allocated to an officer. I am prepared to stand my ground. RE: Horizon Parking PCN - b789 - 11-16-2026 @Tortfeasor, good. If you are prepared to stand your ground, the unsuccessful POPLA appeal changes very little. POPLA’s decision is not binding upon you, and Horizon cannot rely upon it as proof of liability. If Horizon wants payment, it must ultimately prove its case before a judge on the evidence and the law. A court should examine the issues afresh. Horizon would still need to establish keeper liability, including that the original NtK was actually posted within the statutory process. Producing a copy months later does not prove posting, particularly when the promised “case records” were absent, the issue dates conflict and the NtK was omitted from the SAR response. The signage evidence would also be considered on its merits. Your nighttime photographs and footage directly address the conditions when the alleged contract was supposedly formed, whereas Horizon relied upon old daylight photographs. The continuing presence of the YourParkingSpace signs is also relevant because Horizon would have to explain how their offer of parking for more than three hours operates alongside its purported one-hour restriction. If the notices create genuinely different possible meanings, section 69 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 requires the meaning most favourable to the consumer to prevail. Keep the latest ICO response and preserve all existing evidence. It may also be sensible to retain a dated record showing that the entrance sign remains illegible at night even after the tree has shed its leaves, but there is no need to keep revisiting the site or accumulating endless photographs. For now, expect demands and powerless debt-recovery letters. File them in the bin and do not engage with powerless debt collectors. If Horizon or a solicitor sends a formal Letter of Claim, or if a County Court claim arrives, update the thread immediately and we will deal with it properly. RE: Horizon Parking PCN - Tortfeasor - 11-16-2026 Thank you again, @b789. I was just reading about New Generation Parking Management Ltd v RandG. That was a very interesting one! You can be sure I’ll be updating the thread if/when I receive a Letter of Claim or a County Court claim. |