Private Parking Ticket Legal Advice (PPTLA)
PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - Printable Version

+- Private Parking Ticket Legal Advice (PPTLA) (https://pptla.uk)
+-- Forum: Legal advice forum (https://pptla.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Parking Charge Notices forum (https://pptla.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester (/showthread.php?tid=75)



PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - Dom.mcck - 04-18-2026

This case concerns a Parking Charge Notice (private parking firm) issued by National Parking Control Group Ltd, relating to an alleged contravention on Friday, 17 April 2026. The notice itself is dated Friday, 17 April 2026, and I first became aware of it via received initial notice.

The notice appears to have been issued as On vehicle (windscreen ticket only). Driver identified status: NO. Equality Act considerations: No. The location is stated as The Foundry, Chichester.

A preliminary Protection of Freedoms Act (PoFA) assessment indicates WAITING: This is still pre-NtK under PoFA paragraph 8. Wait for a postal NtK. Route applied: Pre-NtK stage after windscreen NtD. The notice is treated as given on Not available (1 days after the alleged event).

Current stage:
- Notice responded to: No
- Debt recovery letters: No
- Letter of Claim: No
- County Court claim: No

Additional notes provided:
I put my reg in the system in the pub and it said it was valid until 07:00. No AM or PM listed so I assumed the parking is 24hrs but it was 12hrs. The length of time wasn’t listed anywhere. I have attached an image of an example of how the time is formatted on the iPad.
I was a paying customer at the pub but just misunderstood the parking system.

Please can I have advice on the strongest next steps and defence points for this case.


RE: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - b789 - 04-18-2026

Hi @Dom.mcck. Can you show the image. No image was attached to the post.

As this is a windscreen Notice to Driver (NtD) it would assist greatly if you could also show me an image of the PCN that was affixed to the vehicle. Both sides please. Any photos of the signs in situ would also assist.

Have you been back to the pub to ask the management to get it cancelled?

As with any windscreen NtD, you must not act in haste. They have no idea who the driver is and unless their NtD fully complies with PoFA and their follow up also complies, they cannot hold you liable as the Keeper as long as the driver is not identified.

National Parking Control Group are IPC members so any appeals are not going to be accepted, either initially or secondary with the IAS. However, in most cases, these will progress to a county court claim which will either be subsequently discontinued or easily won because of their failures to comply with all the requirements of PoFA.

What you must NOT do is respond to the NtD until day 27 after the date of the initial issue of the NtD. That is when you must submit an initial appeal, only as the Keeper and you must not identify the driver.

So, on Thursday 14 May is when you send the appeal. I will give you the wording to use once you have shown me the NtD and any pictures of the signs etc.

Do not rush this. There is a tactical reason for appealing at the last moment and that is often enough to give you a huge advantage in dealing with these ex-clampers.


RE: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - Dom.mcck - 04-28-2026

Hi,
Apologies for the lack of photos, my mistake. I can only upload 2MB at a time so my photos won’t attach.
Pub staff said there’s nothing they can do and I should just appeal based on the unclear timeframe.
Apologies for the poor quality photos of the NtD, it’s difficult to take clear pictures of it.
Also note that the discounted rate expires in 3 days so if it’s PoFA compliant and if the grounds I suggested aren’t likely going to win an appeal please let me know ASAP. 
Thanks

Here is the photo of the iPad in the pub. (Max 5 attachments on each post so had to make a new one)


RE: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - b789 - 04-28-2026

Thanks for the images. Do not identify the driver.

The photos are useful. The PCN reference appears to be APP369922. The windscreen notice has several problems, but the immediate tactical point is that this is still only a Notice to Driver (NtD). National Parking Control Group do not yet have Keeper liability unless they later serve a fully compliant Notice to Keeper (NtK) and comply with every requirement of Schedule 4 of PoFA.

The windscreen NtD states that appeals must be received within 21 days, but that is not compliant with the Private Parking Single Code of Practice. Section 8.4.1 requires parking operators to provide a process allowing the parking charge to be appealed within 28 days of receipt. National Parking Control Group cannot shorten that appeal period simply by printing an old IPC-style 21-day deadline on the notice.

The tactical appeal timing therefore remains around day 27. For a notice dated Friday 17 April 2026, the Keeper appeal should be submitted on Thursday 14 May 2026. Submit it as Keeper only. Do not say who was driving.

The 21-day wording is itself another complaint point. It misleads motorists into believing they have less time to appeal than the PPSCoP requires. If their portal refuses to accept an appeal after 21 days but within 28 days, take screenshots and send the appeal by email immediately, expressly stating that refusal to accept it is a breach of PPSCoP section 8.4.1.

In the meantime, go back to the pub and ask the manager (not lowly staff) to get this cancelled. Show proof that the occupants were genuine customers and explain that the vehicle registration was entered into the pub kiosk, but the kiosk displayed the expiry time in a way that was not clear. Do not say who was driving. Refer only to “the driver” or “the occupants”.

The sign does not clearly say there is a 12-hour maximum registration period. It says Foundry customers must register their vehicle into the kiosk “for the full duration of stay”. That is exactly what the driver understood had been done. If their own kiosk system created confusion by displaying a time without clearly explaining the 12-hour expiry, that ambiguity is their problem.

The driver did enter the VRM into the kiosk. The kiosk displayed a validity time of “18th of April 2026 at 03:40”, but the system/example evidence suggests the time display is ambiguous because it does not clearly explain the duration limit or distinguish the basis on which the validity period is calculated.

The signage does not clearly state that customer registration is capped at 12 hours. The signage does not clearly warn that a genuine customer can become liable for £100 despite having registered their VRM into the pub’s own terminal.

The NtD then reframes the alleged issue as absence of a “valid NPC e-permit”, but the mechanism for obtaining that alleged permit is the kiosk, and the motorist cannot be liable where the operator’s own system and signage fail to give clear notice of the relevant limitation.

So, the alleged contravention is stated as “All vehicles must hold a valid NPC e-permit”. The vehicle was used by genuine Foundry customers and the vehicle registration was entered into the kiosk provided for that purpose. The signage states that Foundry customers must register their full and correct vehicle registration into the kiosk for the full duration of stay. That is what was done. The signage does not clearly state that registration is limited to 12 hours, nor does it clearly warn that a customer who has registered their vehicle into the kiosk may still be treated as not holding a valid NPC e-permit because of an undisclosed or inadequately explained expiry period. If the operator’s position is that the e-permit expired, the operator is put to strict proof of the precise expiry mechanism, the exact wording displayed to the user before confirmation, and the contractual basis on which a genuine customer who used the kiosk can nevertheless be liable for £100.

Use this on day 27, i.e. Thursday 14 May 2026. Submit as the Keeper only. Do not add anything identifying the driver.

Quote:Subject: Appeal against Parking Charge Notice APP369922

I appeal as the Registered Keeper. I am under no obligation to identify the driver and I will not be doing so.

The Parking Charge is denied and must be cancelled.

The vehicle was present at The Foundry while the occupants were genuine customers. The vehicle registration was entered into the kiosk provided inside the premises for that purpose. The signage states that Foundry customers must register their full and correct vehicle registration into the kiosk located within the main entrance immediately on arrival, for the full duration of stay. That is precisely what was understood to have been done.

The alleged contravention is stated as “All vehicles must hold a valid NPC e-permit”. If the operator’s position is that an NPC e-permit was created through use of the kiosk but later expired, the operator is put to strict proof of that allegation. The signage shown at the site does not clearly state that a customer registration is limited to 12 hours. It does not clearly state that a genuine customer who has entered the vehicle registration into the kiosk may nevertheless become liable for £100 because of a hidden, ambiguous, or inadequately explained expiry period.

The kiosk display is also ambiguous. The displayed validity time uses a format which does not properly explain the duration of the parking permission, the basis on which the expiry time is calculated, or the consequence of the expiry. A motorist using the system as a genuine customer cannot be bound by an onerous £100 charge where the alleged limitation is not clearly and prominently brought to their attention before or at the point of registration.

The operator is put to strict proof of all of the following:

  1. The full contemporaneous kiosk record for this vehicle registration.
  2. The precise time at which the vehicle registration was entered into the kiosk.
  3. The precise expiry time allegedly generated by the kiosk.
  4. The full wording displayed on the kiosk before confirmation.
  5. The full wording displayed on the kiosk after confirmation.
  6. Evidence that the kiosk clearly warned users that registration was limited to 12 hours.
  7. Evidence that the signage at the site clearly warned customers that a 12-hour limit applied.
  8. Evidence that the vehicle was not covered by a valid NPC e-permit at the material time.
  9. The alleged period of parking.
  10. The landowner authority entitling National Parking Control Group Ltd to issue and pursue parking charges at this site.

The Notice to Driver also fails to specify any proper period of parking. It merely states that the period of parking is “the period immediately preceding the Time of Issue”. That is not a specified period of parking. It is vague and does not establish the duration of any alleged parking event or any breach of contract.

Further, the Notice to Driver misleadingly states that appeals must be received within 21 days. That is inconsistent with section 8.4.1 of the Private Parking Single Code of Practice, which requires operators to provide a process allowing a parking charge to be appealed within 28 days. This appeal is therefore submitted within the required 28-day appeal period. Any attempt to reject or disregard it because of the operator’s self-imposed 21-day deadline will be treated as a further breach of the Code.

For the avoidance of doubt, there is no admission as to the identity of the driver. If National Parking Control Group Ltd contends that the Registered Keeper is liable, it is put to strict proof of full compliance with Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012. Unless and until such compliance is established, there is no Keeper liability.

Cancel the charge, or provide a full evidence-based rejection dealing with each point above.

Just keep in mind that an initial appeal almost never is successful. Why should it be? There is no money in it for them and they are greedy thieves. However, also consider the fact that they are IPC members and the secondary appeal process is through the IAS, which is nothing but a kangaroo court, owned and operated by the very same company that owns the IPC.

If the appeals are not successful, then the only place where this will easily be defeated is if they issue a county court claim and take it all the way to a hearing. The odds of it ever getting that far are slim to none and even if it did, your chances of success are extremely high.

Remember, do not submit this until Thursday 14 May. Make a note to do this in your diary/calendar.


RE: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - Dom.mcck - 07-30-2026

Hi, my appeal was rejected:

All vehicles must hold a valid NPC e-permit
Having noted your comments, and checking the evidence gathered when issuing the Parking Charge, we are satisfied that the Parking Charge has been issued correctly and your appeal is rejected:
You were not in posession of a valid E-Permit, which is required to park.
The Photographic evidence of your vehicle supports the above statement.
In order for a vehicle to have parked correctly a valid NPC e-permit must be registered prior to parking, at the time of the contravention a valid NPC e-permit had not been registered, therefore you have breached
the parking restrictions within this area and were subsequently issued with a parking charge notice.
In order for a vehicle to have parked correctly a valid NPC E-permit must be applied for and, the photographic evidence attached to this parking charge notice clearly shows at the time of the contravention you have breached the parking restrictions within this area and were subsequently issued with a parking charge notice
Please be advised that it is the motorist's responsibility to ensure they register for their full duration of stay, as
stated by our signage.
In addition to this, you did not register until 4 hours after the time of the contravention.
If you believe this decision is incorrect, you are entitled to appeal to the Independent Appeals Service (IAS). In
order to appeal, you will need your Parking Charge number and your vehicle registration. Appeals must be
submitted to the IAS within 28 days of the date of this letter. Please visit www.theias.org for full details.

I missed my time to appeal as I hadn’t seen the email.
Now I have letters from DCBL trying to recover £170. What do I do


RE: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - b789 - 07-30-2026

No surprises there! Having missed the IAS appeal deadline, you saved me a lot of time producing an appeal that would also have most likely been rejected.

The DCBL letters can be safely ignored. A debt collector has zero power to actually do anything except to try and intimidate the low-hanging fruit on the gullible tree into paying out of ignorance and fear. Those letters mean nothing and they cannot affect your credit or anything else. Use them as kindling or to line the bottom of a cat litter tray.

Come back if/when you receive an actual Letter of Claim (LoC). If they are using DCBL for their debt collection, they are likely to use DCB Legal to issue the claim. Easily beaten. Just read some of the recent threads that have involved them.


RE: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - Dom.mcck - 11-19-2026

Hi, 
Unfortunately DCBL have sent a letter of claim. Could you please direct me on what to do next?
They had sent me emails asking for me to pay, I responded saying I don’t claim responsibility for the debt, then they called me maybe 20 separate times, which I only picked up the last time and further explained I am not responsible for the debt, stop calling.


RE: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - Brenda_R2 - 11-19-2026

(11-19-2026, 01:48 PM)Dom.mcck Wrote: Hi, 
Unfortunately DCBL have sent a letter of claim. Could you please direct me on what to do next?
They had sent me emails asking for me to pay, I responded saying I don’t claim responsibility for the debt, then they called me maybe 20 separate times, which I only picked up the last time and further explained I am not responsible for the debt, stop calling.

Ignore DCBL completely. They are powerless debt collectors and have no powers to enforce payment. Their threatening letters are designed to frighten and intimidate people into paying.

Wait for @b789 to give you your bullet proof get out of jail card.


RE: PCN due to unclear timeframe in Chichester - b789 - 11-19-2026

@Dom.mcck, the letter dated 12 November 2026 is a formal Letter of Claim (LoC) from DCB Legal, not a County Court claim. The £170 demanded consists of the original £100 parking charge plus £70 in additional debt recovery costs.

You should respond directly to DCB Legal, disputing the entire alleged debt and requesting the evidence supporting their client's claim. There is no need to complete their enclosed Reply Form or financial statement. I have a response below that you can email to them.

The principal issue now is whether NPC ever served a compliant Notice to Keeper (NtK). Following the windscreen NtD issued on 17 April 2026, a PoFA-compliant NtK had to be given between 16 May and 12 June 2026. The original NtD is also vulnerable under paragraph 7(2)(a), because its wording does not identify a defined period of parking.

DCB Legal's letter gives 30 days from 12 November to respond. I would send the response by email to info@dcblegal.co.uk and CC yourself, quoting their reference 711201754335NAT, no later than Friday 11 December 2026. The Pre-Action Protocol requires them to provide requested relevant documents or explain why they are unavailable within 30 days.

The additional £70 should also be expressly disputed. Although the PPSSCoP permits a debt recovery fee of up to £70 in principle, that does not automatically make it contractually enforceable or recoverable in this particular case.

email the following in response to the LoC:


Quote:Subject: Formal Dispute – Letter of Claim – Ref: 711201754335NAT

Dear Sirs,

Re: Your Letter of Claim dated 12 November 2026

Your reference: 711201754335NAT
PCN: APP369922
Location: The Foundry, Chichester
Date of alleged contravention: 17 April 2026

I write as the Registered Keeper in response to your Letter of Claim. The alleged debt is disputed in its entirety. No liability is admitted, and there is no admission as to the identity of the driver.

Your assertion that I am liable as the "Keeper or Driver" is insufficient. Your client is required to establish the legal basis on which liability is alleged.

The original Parking Charge Notice was affixed to the vehicle on 17 April 2026. Consequently, any attempt to transfer liability to the Registered Keeper must comply fully with paragraphs 7 and 8 of Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).

The Notice to Driver fails to specify a defined period of parking, contrary to paragraph 7(2)(a). It merely refers to an unspecified period immediately preceding the time of issue. Your client is put to strict proof of compliance with every applicable requirement of Schedule 4.

Furthermore, the vehicle registration was entered into the customer registration kiosk at The Foundry. The signage requires customers to register their vehicle for the duration of their stay but does not clearly disclose any 12-hour registration limitation. The kiosk's presentation of the expiry time was ambiguous. The existence of a contractual breach is therefore disputed.

Pursuant to paragraphs 5.1 and 5.2 of the Pre-Action Protocol for Debt Claims, I require the following documents and information:

1. Copies of the original Notice to Driver and every subsequent Notice to Keeper, together with evidence of their dates of posting and delivery.
2. All contemporaneous photographic evidence relied upon, including photographs identifying the alleged contravention and period of parking.
3. Copies of the contractual signage in place on 17 April 2026, including a site plan identifying its positioning.
4. The complete vehicle registration and e-permit records held by the kiosk system for the material date, including the registration and expiry times.
5. Evidence of the information displayed to customers on the kiosk at the material time, specifically any notification of a 12-hour limitation.
6. The precise contractual term allegedly breached and the legal basis upon which the Registered Keeper is pursued.
7. Evidence of your client's authority from the landowner to issue and pursue parking charges at this location.
8. A full breakdown of the additional £70 claimed, identifying its contractual basis and explaining why this sum is recoverable in addition to the original £100 parking charge.

The additional £70 is expressly disputed. Your client must establish that it was properly incorporated into any alleged contract and is legally recoverable.

I also formally object to the repeated telephone contact made by debt collection agents concerning this disputed charge. Approximately 20 calls were received, and I expressly requested that telephone contact cease. All further communications must be in writing. Please ensure your client and its agents comply with this instruction.

This letter constitutes a formal dispute and request for information under the Pre-Action Protocol for Debt Claims. Please confirm that proceedings will not be commenced while the requested information remains outstanding and before I have had a reasonable opportunity to consider your substantive response.

Should your client commence proceedings without addressing these matters, its conduct and any failure to comply with the Protocol will be brought to the court's attention.

Yours faithfully,

Registered Keeper