Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Instant notice to keeper, no first letter PCN received?
#1
Hi,

I once again have a PCN, this time I instantly got a notice to keeper, i didn't receive the first initial PCN letter for some reason? This is like my other PCN's on here, just me delivering, and I've been hit with another PCN.. 

The PCN is attached, i couldn't find the site entry and leave time on the PCN or on the website at all. Their site doesn't even have an evidence section? How would I go to beat this PCN? Can't even find the time I was there for to argue the 10 minute grace period thing..

I'm going to get alot of PCN's since these company's don't care about people delivering apparently. I deliver in my personal car for Amazon Flex, so not a branded delivery vehicle..


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
       
#2
@cringepcnskekw, first of all, this is the original Notice to Keeper (NtK). There is no requirement for P4Parking to have issued an earlier notice where the alleged contravention was recorded by camera.

The NtK does not specify a period of parking, as required by paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA). Simply stating that the period of parking immediately preceded the alleged contravention time is not sufficient. This is already a potential ground for challenging keeper liability.

However, there is something else I want you to take seriously, particularly as you appear to be accumulating these parking charges while making Amazon Flex deliveries.

You need to start keeping meticulous records of every delivery you undertake. This includes your Amazon Flex delivery schedules, delivery addresses, timestamps, route information and any other evidence that establishes where you were and what you were doing at the time. Screenshots of your delivery history, delivery confirmations and anything else that can corroborate the delivery activity should be saved somewhere secure.

The reason this is so important is the persuasive county court appeal judgment in Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), case number B9GF0A9E. In that case, His Honour Judge Harris QC distinguished between parking and the temporary stopping of a vehicle for loading or unloading. The judgment specifically referred to delivery drivers, including postmen and tradespeople, carrying out deliveries rather than parking.

This could be one of your strongest arguments in these cases. A vehicle temporarily stopped for the purpose of making a genuine delivery is not necessarily parked, regardless of whether it is a branded delivery van or your own private car. However, the circumstances and duration of the stop matter, which is why evidence of the actual delivery activity is so important.

If P4Parking or any other operator eventually issues a county court claim, being able to produce contemporaneous evidence showing that the vehicle was being used for genuine delivery activity at the relevant location could make a considerable difference to your defence.

For this particular NtK, please confirm whether you can retrieve your Amazon Flex delivery records for 24 October 2026 at approximately 13:32, including the relevant delivery address and any timestamps.

In the meantime, do not identify the driver to P4Parking. We can deal with the NtK on the basis of keeper liability, but I want you to appreciate the importance of preserving delivery evidence for this and any future cases.

Paste the following as your initial appeal, which is almost certainly going to be rejected so that we can get a POPLA code for the fuller secondary appeal:

Quote:I am the registered keeper of the vehicle identified above. I dispute this parking charge and require its cancellation.

Your Notice to Keeper (NtK) fails to comply with the requirements of Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).

In particular, paragraph 9(2)(a) requires the NtK to specify the period of parking to which the notice relates. Your NtK specifies only a single alleged contravention time. The statement that the period of parking immediately preceded that time does not identify any period of parking and fails to satisfy this mandatory requirement.

Furthermore, the photographs provided do not establish any period of parking or demonstrate that the vehicle was parked in breach of any contractual terms. Your online appeals portal provides no additional photographic evidence or records establishing the alleged contravention.

Consequently, you have failed to establish any liability on the part of the registered keeper. There is no legal presumption that the registered keeper was the driver, and I am under no obligation to identify the driver.

I require you to cancel this parking charge. Should you refuse, you must issue a rejection containing a valid POPLA verification code so that the matter can be referred to independent appeal.

I do not expect any further correspondence other than confirmation of cancellation or a formal rejection accompanied by a POPLA code.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#3
(11-07-2026, 03:49 PM)b789 Wrote: @cringepcnskekw, first of all, this is the original Notice to Keeper (NtK). There is no requirement for P4Parking to have issued an earlier notice where the alleged contravention was recorded by camera.

The NtK does not specify a period of parking, as required by paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA). Simply stating that the period of parking immediately preceded the alleged contravention time is not sufficient. This is already a potential ground for challenging keeper liability.

However, there is something else I want you to take seriously, particularly as you appear to be accumulating these parking charges while making Amazon Flex deliveries.

You need to start keeping meticulous records of every delivery you undertake. This includes your Amazon Flex delivery schedules, delivery addresses, timestamps, route information and any other evidence that establishes where you were and what you were doing at the time. Screenshots of your delivery history, delivery confirmations and anything else that can corroborate the delivery activity should be saved somewhere secure.

The reason this is so important is the persuasive county court appeal judgment in Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), case number B9GF0A9E. In that case, His Honour Judge Harris QC distinguished between parking and the temporary stopping of a vehicle for loading or unloading. The judgment specifically referred to delivery drivers, including postmen and tradespeople, carrying out deliveries rather than parking.

This could be one of your strongest arguments in these cases. A vehicle temporarily stopped for the purpose of making a genuine delivery is not necessarily parked, regardless of whether it is a branded delivery van or your own private car. However, the circumstances and duration of the stop matter, which is why evidence of the actual delivery activity is so important.

If P4Parking or any other operator eventually issues a county court claim, being able to produce contemporaneous evidence showing that the vehicle was being used for genuine delivery activity at the relevant location could make a considerable difference to your defence.

For this particular NtK, please confirm whether you can retrieve your Amazon Flex delivery records for 24 October 2026 at approximately 13:32, including the relevant delivery address and any timestamps.

In the meantime, do not identify the driver to P4Parking. We can deal with the NtK on the basis of keeper liability, but I want you to appreciate the importance of preserving delivery evidence for this and any future cases.

Paste the following as your initial appeal, which is almost certainly going to be rejected so that we can get a POPLA code for the fuller secondary appeal:

Quote:I am the registered keeper of the vehicle identified above. I dispute this parking charge and require its cancellation.

Your Notice to Keeper (NtK) fails to comply with the requirements of Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).

In particular, paragraph 9(2)(a) requires the NtK to specify the period of parking to which the notice relates. Your NtK specifies only a single alleged contravention time. The statement that the period of parking immediately preceded that time does not identify any period of parking and fails to satisfy this mandatory requirement.

Furthermore, the photographs provided do not establish any period of parking or demonstrate that the vehicle was parked in breach of any contractual terms. Your online appeals portal provides no additional photographic evidence or records establishing the alleged contravention.

Consequently, you have failed to establish any liability on the part of the registered keeper. There is no legal presumption that the registered keeper was the driver, and I am under no obligation to identify the driver.

I require you to cancel this parking charge. Should you refuse, you must issue a rejection containing a valid POPLA verification code so that the matter can be referred to independent appeal.

I do not expect any further correspondence other than confirmation of cancellation or a formal rejection accompanied by a POPLA code.

"For this particular NtK, please confirm whether you can retrieve your Amazon Flex delivery records for 24 October 2026 at approximately 13:32, including the relevant delivery address and any timestamps."

So Amazon don't give you this information, all they give you is the day, and the route start/end time, no information about where I delivered to or anything like that. I've tried emailing them, but their policy is they don't give that information out.. From now on when I go in these dodgy car parks, I'll just screenshot the app, and delete it after 14/30 days?

I also heard from others like on facebook that you should reply to PCN's on the last day to overload them or something i forgot what they said. Does this help us at all to reply on the final day?

Thanks for the reply Smile
#4
@cringepcnskekw, if Amazon will not provide detailed delivery records retrospectively, you need to start keeping your own evidence.

Taking screenshots of the Amazon Flex app showing the delivery address, date, time and any confirmation of delivery is an excellent idea. However,do not delete those screenshots after 14 or 30 days!

A parking operator has up to six years to commence a county court claim, so evidence that could help defend one of these charges needs to be retained for that period. Ideally, save the screenshots in a dedicated folder, organised by date, along with any other evidence showing that you were making deliveries.

This is particularly important because ofJopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), which distinguishes genuine loading and unloading activities from parking. The more evidence you can preserve of your delivery activities, the stronger your position will be if any of these parking charges eventually reaches court.

Regarding appealing on the final day, there is no general advantage in doing so. You may have seen advice about submitting an appeal on day 26 or 27, but that relates to a particular tactic involving a windscreen Notice to Driver (NtD), where the objective is to encourage the operator to overlook the statutory requirements for issuing a subsequent Notice to Keeper.

That tactic does not apply here because you have already received a postal NtK. There is nothing to gain by deliberately delaying your appeal until the final day, and doing so simply increases the risk of missing the deadline.

For this P4Parking charge, submit the keeper appeal already drafted and await either confirmation of cancellation or a POPLA code. Do not identify the driver.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#5
(11-09-2026, 04:54 PM)b789 Wrote: @cringepcnskekw, if Amazon will not provide detailed delivery records retrospectively, you need to start keeping your own evidence.

Taking screenshots of the Amazon Flex app showing the delivery address, date, time and any confirmation of delivery is an excellent idea. However,do not delete those screenshots after 14 or 30 days!

A parking operator has up to six years to commence a county court claim, so evidence that could help defend one of these charges needs to be retained for that period. Ideally, save the screenshots in a dedicated folder, organised by date, along with any other evidence showing that you were making deliveries.

This is particularly important because ofJopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), which distinguishes genuine loading and unloading activities from parking. The more evidence you can preserve of your delivery activities, the stronger your position will be if any of these parking charges eventually reaches court.

Regarding appealing on the final day, there is no general advantage in doing so. You may have seen advice about submitting an appeal on day 26 or 27, but that relates to a particular tactic involving a windscreen Notice to Driver (NtD), where the objective is to encourage the operator to overlook the statutory requirements for issuing a subsequent Notice to Keeper.

That tactic does not apply here because you have already received a postal NtK. There is nothing to gain by deliberately delaying your appeal until the final day, and doing so simply increases the risk of missing the deadline.

For this P4Parking charge, submit the keeper appeal already drafted and await either confirmation of cancellation or a POPLA code. Do not identify the driver.

Hi,

Received the expected rejection email..


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
       
#6
@cringepcnskekw, as expected, P4Parking has rejected your appeal without properly addressing the fundamental failure of its Notice to Keeper (NtK) to comply with the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).

However, its rejection has revealed some useful additional information.

Firstly, P4Parking now claims that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds. That information was conspicuously absent from the original NtK, which specified only a single alleged contravention time of 13:32.

Paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 of PoFA expressly requires the NtK to specify the period of parking. The vague statement in the original notice that the period of parking immediately preceded the alleged contravention time does not satisfy that requirement. Providing an alleged duration in a subsequent appeal rejection cannot retrospectively remedy the defective NtK.

Secondly, P4Parking claims that the 14 minutes and 20 seconds exceeded an alleged 10-minute grace period. However, the consideration period and grace period are two distinct concepts under the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice. Simply asserting that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds does not establish that the driver accepted any contractual terms or that a parking contract was breached.

There is also an interesting inconsistency. The alleged contravention is "No valid digital permit", yet P4Parking refers to a 10-minute grace period displayed on its signage. We need to examine the actual signage to establish precisely what contractual terms it claims were breached.

Thirdly, we still have the potential argument arising from Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), which distinguishes genuine loading and unloading activities from parking. This could be particularly relevant given that the vehicle was being used for Amazon Flex deliveries, although evidence of the actual delivery activity would strengthen that argument considerably.

The next step is POPLA. Our primary argument will be that P4Parking has failed to establish keeper liability under PoFA. We can also challenge the alleged period of parking, the signage, and the operator's landowner authority.

Do not respond further to P4Parking.

Before I draft your POPLA appeal, please upload the remaining pages of the rejection, particularly any photographs of the signage or other evidence they have provided. These may reveal further weaknesses in their case.

When you upload photos, please use a higher resolution that the one you just provided as they are incredibly difficult to read properly.

You have 33 days (28 + 5 for service) from the issue of the POPLA code to submit your appeal, so there is no need to rush it. We want to ensure that every available appeal ground is properly addressed.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#7
@cringepcnskekw . Hopefully a side issue, but does your vehicle insurance cover business use?
#8
(11-12-2026, 06:25 PM)b789 Wrote: @cringepcnskekw, as expected, P4Parking has rejected your appeal without properly addressing the fundamental failure of its Notice to Keeper (NtK) to comply with the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).

However, its rejection has revealed some useful additional information.

Firstly, P4Parking now claims that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds. That information was conspicuously absent from the original NtK, which specified only a single alleged contravention time of 13:32.

Paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 of PoFA expressly requires the NtK to specify the period of parking. The vague statement in the original notice that the period of parking immediately preceded the alleged contravention time does not satisfy that requirement. Providing an alleged duration in a subsequent appeal rejection cannot retrospectively remedy the defective NtK.

Secondly, P4Parking claims that the 14 minutes and 20 seconds exceeded an alleged 10-minute grace period. However, the consideration period and grace period are two distinct concepts under the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice. Simply asserting that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds does not establish that the driver accepted any contractual terms or that a parking contract was breached.

There is also an interesting inconsistency. The alleged contravention is "No valid digital permit", yet P4Parking refers to a 10-minute grace period displayed on its signage. We need to examine the actual signage to establish precisely what contractual terms it claims were breached.

Thirdly, we still have the potential argument arising from Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), which distinguishes genuine loading and unloading activities from parking. This could be particularly relevant given that the vehicle was being used for Amazon Flex deliveries, although evidence of the actual delivery activity would strengthen that argument considerably.

The next step is POPLA. Our primary argument will be that P4Parking has failed to establish keeper liability under PoFA. We can also challenge the alleged period of parking, the signage, and the operator's landowner authority.

Do not respond further to P4Parking.

Before I draft your POPLA appeal, please upload the remaining pages of the rejection, particularly any photographs of the signage or other evidence they have provided. These may reveal further weaknesses in their case.

When you upload photos, please use a higher resolution that the one you just provided as they are incredibly difficult to read properly.

You have 33 days (28 + 5 for service) from the issue of the POPLA code to submit your appeal, so there is no need to rush it. We want to ensure that every available appeal ground is properly addressed.
Hi,

These are the remaining pages of the rejection email they sent. I can only upload 2 images due to file size, so I'll upload the AI enhanced image of the sign below, or would you need me to go back and take a proper picture? I'll be back in that area tomorrow.

Thanks

(11-12-2026, 06:25 PM)b789 Wrote: @cringepcnskekw, as expected, P4Parking has rejected your appeal without properly addressing the fundamental failure of its Notice to Keeper (NtK) to comply with the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).

However, its rejection has revealed some useful additional information.

Firstly, P4Parking now claims that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds. That information was conspicuously absent from the original NtK, which specified only a single alleged contravention time of 13:32.

Paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 of PoFA expressly requires the NtK to specify the period of parking. The vague statement in the original notice that the period of parking immediately preceded the alleged contravention time does not satisfy that requirement. Providing an alleged duration in a subsequent appeal rejection cannot retrospectively remedy the defective NtK.

Secondly, P4Parking claims that the 14 minutes and 20 seconds exceeded an alleged 10-minute grace period. However, the consideration period and grace period are two distinct concepts under the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice. Simply asserting that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds does not establish that the driver accepted any contractual terms or that a parking contract was breached.

There is also an interesting inconsistency. The alleged contravention is "No valid digital permit", yet P4Parking refers to a 10-minute grace period displayed on its signage. We need to examine the actual signage to establish precisely what contractual terms it claims were breached.

Thirdly, we still have the potential argument arising from Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), which distinguishes genuine loading and unloading activities from parking. This could be particularly relevant given that the vehicle was being used for Amazon Flex deliveries, although evidence of the actual delivery activity would strengthen that argument considerably.

The next step is POPLA. Our primary argument will be that P4Parking has failed to establish keeper liability under PoFA. We can also challenge the alleged period of parking, the signage, and the operator's landowner authority.

Do not respond further to P4Parking.

Before I draft your POPLA appeal, please upload the remaining pages of the rejection, particularly any photographs of the signage or other evidence they have provided. These may reveal further weaknesses in their case.

When you upload photos, please use a higher resolution that the one you just provided as they are incredibly difficult to read properly.

You have 33 days (28 + 5 for service) from the issue of the POPLA code to submit your appeal, so there is no need to rush it. We want to ensure that every available appeal ground is properly addressed.

Hopefully this AI enhanced picture is ok? If not i'll go back tomorrow.


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
           
#9
@cringepcnskekw, are you sure that those signs and images are for this PCN. The NtK is for Pay4Parking. The signs you have shown are for Highview Parking. 

This thread is about the Pay4Parking PCN you received.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#10
(11-13-2026, 07:18 PM)b789 Wrote: @cringepcnskekw, are you sure that those signs and images are for this PCN. The NtK is for Pay4Parking. The signs you have shown are for Highview Parking. 

This thread is about the Pay4Parking PCN you received.

Ohh i just used AI to enhance the picture and not sure why it says that random parking company. I will go back tomorrow or Monday and take a clearer picture.


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Received POC from BWLegal on behalf of UK CPM Ltd Barbudaprince 46 9,579 11-07-2026, 08:01 PM
Last Post: Barbudaprince
  Re: dcbl letter of debt recovery says 'Unpaid CCJ' Rosa23 46 4,305 11-03-2026, 02:58 PM
Last Post: Rosa23
  PCN - received while vehicle was being loaded for 10 minutes. KHarHar 19 2,659 10-29-2026, 12:31 PM
Last Post: KHarHar
  Claim form received from two alleged contraventions 3 years ago - SMART PARKING JoeBloggs90 21 4,878 10-13-2026, 02:13 PM
Last Post: b789
  Received a PCN whilst outside of the country JParker 5 1,026 09-29-2026, 10:53 AM
Last Post: b789
  Gladstones Letter Before Claim - NPM PCN - No e-Permit - Woodgrange Road E7 armz247 9 1,982 09-19-2026, 09:07 AM
Last Post: b789
  Received a HM Claim form, not sure what to do! Dreamscape 4 962 08-25-2026, 07:27 PM
Last Post: Dreamscape
  Total Parking Solutions - Stamford - Oak Legal letter stage Alexander6 3 684 08-20-2026, 08:34 AM
Last Post: b789
  CMA fines Euro Car Parks £473k for failure to comply with legal information notice b789 2 1,131 08-18-2026, 05:58 PM
Last Post: b789
  DCB Legal - court letter adegaw 21 5,684 08-18-2026, 05:40 PM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)