Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
UKPC ticket whilst driver was delivering parcels on moat lane, nine elms.
#11
@zyno, this is a standard fishing exercise by UKPC to discover the identity of the driver.

Do not identify the driver or provide any further information about who was driving. The keeper has no legal obligation to do so.

UKPC's explanation of PoFA is misleading. Keeper liability does not arise simply because the driver has not been identified. UKPC must first comply with the mandatory requirements of Schedule 4, which your appeal has already challenged.

If. you want, you can respond briefly:

Quote:Dear UKPC Appeals Department,

I refer to your letter dated 26 October 2026.

My appeal was submitted solely in my capacity as registered keeper. I am under no legal obligation to identify the driver and will not be doing so.

Your assertion concerning Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 overlooks the mandatory statutory conditions that must be satisfied before keeper liability can arise.

My original appeal stands in its entirety. Please now either cancel the parking charge or issue a formal rejection accompanied by a POPLA verification code.

Yours faithfully,

Registered Keeper

There is no need to elaborate further or repeat the original appeal. UKPC has confirmed that the charge remains on hold. We now await their decision and, if rejected, take the matter to POPLA.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#12
I haven’t provided any information about the driver or who was driving. I haven’t responded to them yet & will not, I’ll just wait until they give me a POPLA verification code & take it on from there. 
Just wanted to inform you about the email. 
Thank you!
#13
@b789 Hi there, UKPC have sent me an email which states that they have denied my appeal. They have also given me a POPLA verification code too. If you could assist me on how we could go further with this that would be great. 
I have attached a screenshot of the email below. 
Thank you!


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   
#14
@zyno, This is the expected rejection from UKPC. Nothing to worry about. We now move on to POPLA, where we can challenge UKPC's failure to establish keeper liability under PoFA, the prohibitory signage and the absence of any demonstrated contractual liability.

Do not identify the driver at any stage. The POPLA appeal must be submitted solely in your capacity as the registered keeper.

Your POPLA verification code should remain valid for 33 days from the date of UKPC's rejection letter, so there is no need to rush.

Please remind me in a day or two, and I'll put together a suitable POPLA appeal based on the evidence we've already examined. In the meantime, don't respond further to UKPC or submit anything to POPLA.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#15
@b789 just giving you a reminder as it’s been 2 days I believe. But no rush as you said I have 33 days from receiving the verification code to appeal to POPLA. 
Thank you Big Grin
#16
@zyno, copy and paste the POPLA appeal below into a document, complete the placeholders with your details and save it as a PDF. Then submit the appeal through the POPLA online portal, uploading the PDF.

When completing the POPLA online form, make sure you only select options identifying yourself as the registered Keeper or "Other". Do not select anything that identifies or implies that you were the driver.

In the box requesting your reasons for appealing, simply enter:

"See uploaded PDF appeal"

Make sure the pdf has been successfully uploaded before submitting the appeal.

Quote:POPLA APPEAL

Appellant: Registered Keeper
Operator: UK Parking Control Ltd (UKPC)
POPLA Verification Code: [Insert code]
Parking Charge Reference: [Insert reference]
Vehicle Registration: [Insert VRM]
Date of Alleged Contravention: 26 September 2026
Location: Nine Elms Park – Zone 1, Mount Lane, Nine Elms Park, Embassy Gardens, New Union Square, Ponton Road, Nine Elms, London SW11 7DN

Introduction

I am the registered keeper of the vehicle identified in the above Parking Charge Notice (PCN). I appeal solely in that capacity. The identity of the driver has not been established, and I am under no legal obligation to identify that person.

The operator alleges that the vehicle was "Parked in a roadway" and seeks to recover a parking charge of £100. I dispute the charge and the operator's entitlement to recover it from me.

My appeal is made on the following grounds:

1. Failure to comply with Schedule 4, paragraph 9(2)(f) of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA) – defective statutory warning.
2. Failure to specify the period of parking as required by PoFA paragraph 9(2)(a).
3. No evidence that the appellant was the driver and no lawful presumption of driver identity.
4. Prohibitory signage – no demonstrated contractual offer capable of acceptance.
5. Inadequate and contradictory signage – failure to establish contractual terms applicable to the roadway.
6. Insufficient evidence of the alleged contravention and actual period of parking.
7. No evidence of sufficient landowner authority to issue and pursue the charge.

1. Failure to comply with PoFA Schedule 4, paragraph 9(2)(f) – defective statutory warning

The operator seeks to invoke Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA) to transfer liability for an alleged parking charge from an unidentified driver to the registered keeper. However, the statutory mechanism is only available where the operator has complied with all applicable mandatory requirements. The operator cannot selectively apply those requirements or substitute materially different wording for the warning prescribed by Parliament.

Paragraph 9(2)(f) requires the Notice to Keeper (NtK) to warn the keeper that, after the prescribed period of 28 days, the creditor will have the right to recover the unpaid parking charge from the keeper if the amount remains unpaid and the creditor does not know both the name of the driver and a current address for service for that driver. These are cumulative statutory conditions, not alternatives.

UKPC's NtK states:

"If, after a period of 28 days (beginning on the day after this Parking Charge is given), the amount requested in this Parking Charge has not been paid in full (or we have not been informed of the driver's name and current address), you, the registered keeper, will, subject to the conditions of, and under the terms of Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012, be liable to pay the unpaid Parking Charge."

The operator has expressly used the word "or", thereby presenting the two statutory conditions as alternatives rather than cumulative requirements. On its ordinary meaning, this wording suggests that keeper liability may arise where either the charge remains unpaid or the operator has not been informed of the driver's details. This materially misrepresents the statutory position, since paragraph 9(2)(f) requires both conditions to be satisfied before the creditor may exercise the statutory right to recover the unpaid charge from the keeper.

Furthermore, PoFA does not require the registered keeper personally to provide the driver's identity. The relevant statutory condition concerns whether the creditor knows both the driver's name and a current address for service, irrespective of how that information was obtained. UKPC's wording instead implies that the keeper's failure to provide those details is itself sufficient to trigger liability. The general qualification referring to the conditions of Schedule 4 does not remedy the incorrect statement of those conditions within the warning itself.

The statutory requirements of Schedule 4 must be satisfied before any liability can be transferred to the keeper. UKPC has failed to give the warning prescribed by paragraph 9(2)(f), and its NtK is therefore incapable of establishing keeper liability. As the operator has not identified the driver, there is no lawful basis upon which it can recover the alleged charge from this appellant.

2. Failure to specify the period of parking – PoFA Schedule 4, paragraph 9(2)(a)

Paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 requires the NtK to "specify the vehicle, the relevant land on which it was parked and the period of parking to which the notice relates". This is a mandatory statutory requirement, and the operator must identify the period during which the vehicle was allegedly parked, rather than merely record its presence within a particular location.

UKPC's NtK states that "The recorded duration of stay was 0 Hours 12 Minutes 31 Seconds". However, the notice does not expressly identify the commencement and conclusion of the alleged period of parking. A stated duration of presence is not necessarily equivalent to a period of parking, particularly where the allegation concerns a roadway rather than a designated parking bay. The distinction is material because a vehicle may be present within an area without necessarily being parked throughout that period.

The operator's allegation is specifically "Parked in a roadway", yet the notice does not establish when the alleged parking began or ended, or that the vehicle was continuously parked for the duration stated. The photographs reproduced on the NtK do not, without further evidence, establish the actual period of parking required by paragraph 9(2)(a). UKPC appears to have substituted a recorded duration of stay for the statutory requirement to specify the period of parking, without demonstrating that the two are equivalent.

I submit that the NtK does not adequately specify the relevant period of parking and therefore fails to comply with paragraph 9(2)(a). This is a further independent ground upon which UKPC's attempt to transfer liability to the registered keeper must fail.

3. No evidence of driver identity – the registered keeper cannot be presumed to have been driving

This appeal is submitted solely in my capacity as the registered keeper. I have not identified the driver, nor have I made any admission concerning the driver's identity. UKPC has produced no evidence establishing that I was driving at the material time, and there is no statutory or common-law presumption that the registered keeper of a vehicle was necessarily its driver.

Schedule 4 of PoFA was enacted specifically to provide a limited statutory mechanism by which private parking operators may, subject to strict conditions, recover certain unpaid parking charges from a keeper where the driver's identity is unknown. The existence of that mechanism demonstrates why an operator cannot simply assume that the registered keeper was driving and pursue that person on the basis of an unsupported presumption. Where the statutory conditions have not been satisfied, any alleged liability remains with the driver, whose identity the operator must establish if it wishes to pursue that individual.

In its correspondence dated 26 October 2026, UKPC requested the driver's full name and address and asserted that PoFA allows operators to hold registered keepers liable where the driver's details have not been provided. That statement omits the essential qualification that keeper liability is conditional upon compliance with the applicable provisions of Schedule 4. There is no legal obligation upon a registered keeper to identify the driver to a private parking operator, and declining to provide that information does not create liability where none otherwise exists.

As demonstrated in Grounds 1 and 2, UKPC's NtK fails to satisfy the statutory conditions necessary to transfer liability. The operator has not identified the driver and cannot rely upon any presumption that the keeper was driving. Consequently, UKPC has failed to establish any lawful basis upon which this appellant can be held personally liable for the alleged parking charge.

4. Prohibitory signage – no demonstrated contractual offer capable of acceptance

The alleged contravention is expressly described on the NtK as "Parked in a roadway". However, the signage at the location prominently displays the words "NO PARKING", reinforced by a crossed-out parking symbol and the additional wording "No Parking". The dominant and unmistakable message conveyed by this signage is that parking is prohibited, rather than permitted subject to the payment of a contractual charge.

The formation of a binding contract requires an identifiable offer, acceptance and consideration. A prohibition against parking does not, merely by its existence, constitute an offer to park in exchange for payment of £100. UKPC must therefore establish how the signage, considered in its entirety, communicated a contractual offer capable of acceptance through the very conduct that the sign expressly prohibits. The existence of smaller printed terms referring to a parking charge, if relied upon by the operator, does not automatically establish that a genuine contractual offer was made or accepted.

The circumstances are materially distinguishable from ParkingEye Ltd v Beavis [2015] UKSC 67, in which the Supreme Court considered a clearly communicated contractual parking arrangement under which motorists were permitted to park subject to specified conditions. In the present case, the principal signage expressly prohibits parking. The operator cannot simply rely upon Beavis without first establishing that an enforceable contract was formed and that its terms were adequately communicated.

If UKPC's allegation is instead founded upon trespass, that would constitute a different cause of action requiring proof of the necessary legal standing to pursue it. A parking contractor does not automatically acquire the landholder's right to recover damages for trespass merely by being authorised to manage parking or issue parking charges. UKPC must establish both the legal basis of its claim and its authority to pursue that particular cause of action.

I submit that the expressly prohibitory wording creates a fundamental difficulty for UKPC's assertion that a contractual parking charge arose. The operator is put to strict proof of the contractual offer allegedly made, the conduct constituting acceptance, the consideration provided and the precise contractual term allegedly breached. Unless those elements are established, there is no enforceable contractual parking charge.

5. Inadequate and contradictory signage – failure to establish contractual terms applicable to the roadway

The photographic evidence demonstrates that UKPC uses two materially different types of signage at the location. The entrance sign states "THIS CAR PARK IS ON PRIVATE LAND" and "PARKING CONDITIONS APPLY", directing motorists to "See notices in car park for terms and conditions and data use". However, the separate sign prominently states "NO PARKING", accompanied by a crossed-out parking symbol. The entrance sign does not itself identify a contractual charge of £100 or explain that parking on a roadway gives rise to such a charge, while the subsequent signage communicates an express prohibition.

This distinction is particularly significant because UKPC alleges that the vehicle was parked on a "roadway", whereas the entrance sign refers specifically to a "car park". The operator must establish that the contractual terms upon which it relies applied to the precise location of the alleged contravention. A general notice stating that parking conditions apply within a development does not, without more, establish that a motorist was adequately informed of specific contractual terms governing a particular roadway.

The Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice requires parking operators to use appropriate, clear and legible signage communicating the terms applicable to the controlled land. UKPC must demonstrate that its signage satisfied the applicable requirements at the material time, including the positioning, prominence and legibility of the contractual terms upon which it relies. A motorist cannot reasonably be expected to accept contractual terms that have not been adequately brought to their attention before any alleged contract is formed.

I require UKPC to provide a contemporaneous site plan identifying the precise location of the vehicle and every sign upon which it relies, together with dated photographs showing the full wording, positioning and visibility of those signs as they existed on 26 September 2026. The operator must also identify the specific contractual provision allegedly breached and demonstrate how that provision was communicated to motorists using the roadway concerned.

The prominent prohibitory wording, combined with the entrance sign's general reference to parking conditions elsewhere, raises substantial questions about the clarity and applicability of the alleged contractual terms. In the absence of satisfactory evidence establishing that those terms were adequately communicated and applicable to the precise location, UKPC has failed to demonstrate that any enforceable contractual obligation arose.

6. Insufficient evidence of the alleged contravention and actual period of parking

The NtK contains two photographic images and states that the recorded duration of stay was 12 minutes and 31 seconds. However, these images and the stated duration do not, without additional evidence, establish that the vehicle remained stationary and parked throughout that period. The operator must demonstrate the specific conduct constituting the alleged contractual breach rather than simply establish that the vehicle was present within a particular area.

The distinction is particularly important because the allegation is not that the vehicle exceeded a permitted parking period within a designated bay, but that it was "Parked in a roadway". The presence of a vehicle on a roadway does not necessarily establish that it was parked in breach of an enforceable contractual term. Depending upon the circumstances, a vehicle may be stationary for reasons that do not constitute parking, and UKPC must establish what actually occurred rather than rely upon assumptions drawn from a recorded duration of presence.

UKPC is therefore put to strict proof of the actual parking event, including contemporaneous, time-stamped evidence demonstrating when the vehicle allegedly became parked, how long that condition persisted and the precise location at which the alleged contravention occurred. If the operator relies upon CCTV, ANPR or other remote observation equipment, it must demonstrate that the recorded times correspond to an actual period of parking rather than merely the interval between observations or the vehicle's entry into and departure from the area.

The operator must also demonstrate that the alleged conduct occurred within the geographical area covered by its enforcement authority and that the specific restriction relied upon applied to that location. A recorded duration of 12 minutes and 31 seconds cannot, by itself, substitute for evidence establishing the alleged breach and the contractual terms said to have been violated.

In the absence of sufficiently detailed and reliable evidence, UKPC has not discharged the burden of establishing that the alleged contravention occurred or that the parking charge was properly issued.

7. No evidence of sufficient landowner authority

UKPC is not identified as the landowner and must therefore establish that it possessed sufficient authority to manage parking, issue parking charges and pursue unpaid charges at the precise location of the alleged contravention. Section 14 of the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice concerns the authority under which parking operators enforce restrictions on land belonging to another party. Mere evidence that UKPC operates somewhere within a larger development does not establish that its authority extends to every roadway, access route or other area within that development.

The location identified on the NtK encompasses several named areas within the Nine Elms development, including Mount Lane, Embassy Gardens, New Union Square and Ponton Road. It is therefore essential that UKPC establishes the precise geographical boundaries of the land subject to its enforcement agreement and demonstrates that the roadway concerned falls within those boundaries. The operator must also establish that its contractual authority was effective on 26 September 2026 and extended to enforcement of the particular restriction allegedly breached.

I require UKPC to produce contemporaneous written authorisation from the landowner, or another party with sufficient legal authority, demonstrating its entitlement to issue and pursue parking charges at the relevant location. That evidence must establish the identity and authority of the contracting parties, the geographical extent of the enforcement area, the applicable parking restrictions and UKPC's authority to pursue unpaid charges in its own name.

A generic site plan, an unparticularised witness statement or an agreement concerning a different part of the development would not, without further evidence, establish the necessary authority over the precise roadway identified in the NtK. Nor would an agreement authorising general parking management necessarily demonstrate standing to pursue an allegation of trespass, should UKPC seek to rely upon that distinct cause of action.

Unless UKPC provides satisfactory evidence establishing its authority over the specific location and its entitlement to pursue the alleged charge, it has failed to demonstrate the necessary legal standing to enforce this demand.

Conclusion

UKPC has failed to establish that I, as registered keeper, am liable for the alleged parking charge. The NtK materially misstates the cumulative statutory conditions required by PoFA paragraph 9(2)(f) and fails adequately to specify the period of parking required by paragraph 9(2)(a). As the driver's identity has not been established, and there is no lawful presumption that the keeper was driving, those defects prevent UKPC from relying upon Schedule 4 to transfer any alleged driver's liability to me.

Independently of those statutory failures, the signage at the location is expressly prohibitory, prominently stating "NO PARKING", while the entrance signage merely refers motorists to other notices concerning parking conditions. UKPC has not demonstrated that a contractual offer capable of acceptance arose, that the relevant contractual terms were adequately communicated and applicable to the precise roadway, or that the alleged conduct constituted a breach of any enforceable contract. Furthermore, the operator has not established the necessary landowner authority to issue and pursue the charge at the location concerned.

Each ground of appeal should be considered independently. It is insufficient for UKPC merely to assert that a parking contravention occurred. The operator must establish both an enforceable underlying charge and a lawful basis for recovering that charge from the registered keeper. In the absence of satisfactory evidence establishing both elements, I respectfully request that POPLA allows this appeal and directs UK Parking Control Ltd to cancel the parking charge.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  UKPC Parking-Parked in an area where no parking allowed w/blue Badge WF1 2DF rhbmcse 29 5,299 11-17-2026, 06:24 PM
Last Post: b789
  Late PCN Demand from UKPC Relevant2Me 10 786 11-10-2026, 09:01 AM
Last Post: Relevant2Me
  Charge from UKPC, Maylands Avenue Retail Park therealrjp 2 297 11-01-2026, 04:33 PM
Last Post: therealrjp
  got this private parking PCN due to delivering.. cringepcnskekw 3 506 10-30-2026, 11:22 AM
Last Post: b789
  UKPC Worcester Blackpole McDonalds Car Park Ogrebear 34 7,915 10-29-2026, 10:47 PM
Last Post: Ogrebear
  PPS pcn, whilst delivering parcels for amazon. zyno 16 1,859 10-24-2026, 12:46 PM
Last Post: b789
  Not parking fully in a bay UKPC LTD Valley Leisure Park crorydon Torenaga 42 11,799 10-16-2026, 02:05 PM
Last Post: Torenaga
  Received a PCN whilst outside of the country JParker 5 1,037 09-29-2026, 10:53 AM
Last Post: b789
  UKPC PCN while delivering for Amazon Flex – POPLA advice needed ibadusaf 7 2,104 08-08-2026, 04:04 PM
Last Post: b789
  UKPC - Motorcycle parked outside bay - Bell Green Retail Park, London sinaloa 26 7,337 07-29-2026, 09:32 AM
Last Post: sinaloa

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)