Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Lease car - appeal period passed
#1
Hi all,

Thanks in advance for your help.

I received letter from Civil Enforcement a few weeks ago relating to all alleged parking infraction on private premises back in Mid August. I went to appeal only to realise that the appeal period had long since expired. Ironically my company is genuine customer of the business and they would have been happy to cancel the ticket - but as the appeal period has passed they are apparently unable to assist.

The car is leased to me personally and is used by various family members  - I presume that CE wrote to the lessor who took a long time to provide the keeper details.

I wrote to CE (by registered post) stating that I did not receive the notice within the prescribed time to exercise my legal right to appeal - and as such requesting that the ticket be set aside as unenforceable.

They of course took no notice of this and today I received an increased bill with threats to  send recovery agents etc.

How should I proceed here? Tough it out? Do I waste another few pounds writing to them again?

Thanks
#2
@Benarty2016, before advising you on how to proceed, we need to establish two important points.

Firstly, as this is a leased vehicle, did Civil Enforcement Ltd (CEL) send you a Notice to Hirer (NtH)? If so, did it include copies of the hire agreement, the statement of liability signed by the hirer and the original Notice to Keeper sent to the leasing company? Please show us the notice you received, with your personal details redacted.

Under Schedule 4, paragraphs 13 and 14 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA), CEL must comply with specific requirements, including supplying the prescribed documents, before it can transfer liability from the unknown driver to the hirer. Failure to comply means CEL cannot hold you liable as the hirer.

Secondly, please reproduce exactly what you wrote to CEL in your letter, particularly any references to who was driving. Did you refer to the driver in the first person, using expressions such as "I parked" or "when I visited", or did you refer to "the driver" in the third person?

This distinction is extremely important. There is no legal obligation to identify the driver to a private parking company. If CEL knows who was driving, it can pursue that person directly without relying on PoFA. However, if the driver's identity remains unknown, CEL must establish liability through strict compliance with PoFA.

CEL, like virtually every other private parking operator, consistently fails to comply with PoFA's requirements for hire and lease vehicles. These are usually straightforward cases to defeat, provided the driver's identity has not been disclosed. Identifying the driver, even inadvertently, can throw away what would otherwise be a complete defence against hirer liability.

You can safely ignore the debt recovery letters. These powerless debt collectors have absolutely no authority to enforce payment, seize goods or affect your credit record. Their entire business model relies on sending increasingly threatening letters, hoping to frighten the low-hanging fruit on the gullible tree into paying out of ignorance and fear. No matter how intimidating these letters appear, they cannot damage your credit record. That would require a court judgment against you, followed by your failure to pay the judgment in full within one calendar month. Debt collectors have no such powers.

Finally, sending letters by registered or signed-for post is a pointless and unnecessary expense. All you need is a free Certificate of Posting from any Post Office, which provides evidence that the letter was posted. Signed-for delivery is particularly unhelpful because a recipient can simply refuse to sign for or accept the letter. All the tracking might then establish is that delivery was unsuccessful.

Once we have seen the NtH and your original letter, we can establish whether CEL has any lawful basis for pursuing you as the hirer.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#3
Hi,

Firstly thank you so much for your generous and detailed reply.

I have attached redacted documents as follows:

1) Reminder Letter received in Oct 2026 (as previously mentioned I have not received any previous correspondence from CE). There was a 2nd page which I have misfiled with a picture that identified the car clearly but not the driver.

2) My letter to CE in October equesting the PCN be set aside

3) A further reminder received yesterday.


Regards

FYI notice that CE in addition to the barcodes, also sneak in identifying codes vertically at the bottom left of their documents so others may want to take care when redacting.


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
           
#4
@Benarty2016, thank you for providing the documents. The good news is that your letter to CEL does not appear to have identified the driver, which is extremely important.

However, there is a fundamental misunderstanding in your letter about your status as the Registered Keeper.

If the vehicle is leased and you do not hold the V5C registration certificate, you are not the Registered Keeper. The leasing company is the Registered Keeper, while you are the Hirer (Lessee). This distinction is critical because different provisions of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA), Schedule 4, apply.

The process normally works as follows. CEL obtains the Registered Keeper's details from the DVLA and sends the original Notice to Keeper (NtK) to the leasing company. The leasing company then responds with the hirer's details and the necessary hire documentation, allowing CEL to pursue the hirer instead. None of this identifies who was driving the vehicle.

CEL must then issue a Notice to Hirer (NtH) and, if it intends to transfer liability to you as the hirer under PoFA, it must comply with paragraphs 13 and 14 of Schedule 4.

Crucially, paragraph 14(2)(a) requires CEL to provide the NtH together with copies of the documents specified in paragraph 13(2), namely:

• The relevant hire agreement.
• The statement of liability signed by the hirer.
• The original Notice to Keeper sent to the leasing company.

If CEL fails to provide these documents with the NtH, it cannot transfer liability to you as the hirer under PoFA. The fact that the leasing company may have supplied those documents to CEL does not excuse CEL from supplying copies to you.

This is precisely why hire and lease vehicle PCNs are usually so straightforward to defeat. Private parking operators, including CEL, routinely fail to comply with these statutory requirements.

Your October letter does not admit that you were driving, so that potentially valuable protection remains intact. The October reminder and subsequent debt recovery letter do not themselves establish compliance with PoFA.

Please confirm whether you received any earlier Notice to Hirer accompanied by all the documents listed above. If you received nothing before the October reminder, and no such documents were enclosed, CEL appears to have failed to establish hirer liability.

For now, there is no reason to pay the £140 demanded or be intimidated by the threatened increase to £170. We first need to establish whether CEL has complied with the legislation.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#5
Thanks for the reply.

I have not received ant prior communication from CEL prior to the first reminder letter previously uploaded - that is why I am so annoyed as not only was the period of appeal already passed, but the business concerned would have been happy to have arranged for the ticket to be cancelled if the appeal period had not passed. My PA who is very precise deals with all the post and she was not happy that I even double checked this with her!

Do they send these notices out by some form of tracked/registered services? 

Regards
#6
@Benarty2016, no, CEL does not normally send its notices by recorded, registered or tracked delivery. Like virtually every other private parking operator, it uses ordinary post, usually through a bulk mailing service. Under PoFA, a notice sent by post is presumed delivered on the second working day after posting, unless the contrary is proved. However, that presumption does not relieve CEL of the burden of establishing that the relevant notice was actually sent.

The important point is that you have not received a Notice to Hirer (NtH), let alone one accompanied by the mandatory documents required under paragraphs 13 and 14 of Schedule 4 of PoFA. Unless CEL can establish that it complied with those requirements, it cannot transfer liability for the alleged parking charge to you as the hirer. Your October letter did not identify the driver, so CEL cannot simply pursue you on that basis either.

I suggest you contact the leasing company and ask them to confirm when they received the original Notice to Keeper, when they responded to CEL and precisely what documents they supplied. This will help establish the sequence of events.

Incidentally, there is no legal reason why the business that contracted CEL cannot request cancellation simply because CEL's appeal deadline has expired. Whether CEL agrees to cancel it is another matter, but the business can still approach CEL and insist that the charge against its genuine customer be cancelled.

For now, ignore the debt recovery threats. Do not pay CEL anything and, above all, do not identify the driver. If CEL eventually issues a formal Letter of Claim, come back here before responding.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#7
I suggest you contact the leasing company and ask them to confirm when they received the original Notice to Keeper, when they responded to CEL and precisely what documents they supplied. This will help establish the sequence of events.

Thank you. I will do that. 

I would never identify the driver as frankly that is none of their business anyway.


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Space included in lease - UK CPM parkinguk 1 314 10-11-2026, 09:41 AM
Last Post: b789
  How to appeal/beat the airport drop-off scam b789 0 379 07-21-2026, 04:27 PM
Last Post: b789
  Exceeding the notified maximum free parking period - Horfield Leisure Centre, Bristol b789 8 3,844 02-12-2026, 05:20 PM
Last Post: b789
Information Why the Independent Appeal Service (IAS) is not fit for purpose b789 0 792 01-22-2026, 12:21 PM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)