Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Received POC from BWLegal on behalf of UK CPM Ltd
#41
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1...ttEqSFxfJ2

See link to the final order. I recieved about 3 separate copies of this same order for unknown reasons...admin error I would assume.

The judge said that because those two pcns where not within the enforcement boundary and parked not on roadways or Access roads, as defined by parking signage, they would be dismissed. 

The car was parked in the same place as the two dismissed PCNs. I would also just comment that there are other cars that park in this area for everyday of the past four years of me living here.

Unfortunately I will be on annual leave out of the country when BW legal send an update PoC so hopefully they will send it via email.
#42
@Barbudaprince, thank you for providing the final court order and clarifying what District Judge Ross said at the earlier hearing. This is potentially very useful evidence for defending the current claim.

The judgment dated 27 August 2026 confirms that UKCPM was awarded £100 plus £199 costs, totalling £299. As the original claim concerned three separate £100 PCNs, the fact that judgment was awarded for only £100 strongly supports your account that UKCPM succeeded on just one PCN and that the other two were dismissed.

More importantly, you have confirmed that the Judge dismissed those two PCNs because the vehicles were parked outside UKCPM's enforcement boundary and were not parked on access roads or roadways, as defined by the signage.

You have also confirmed that the vehicle involved in this new claim was parked in exactly the same location as the vehicles involved in those two dismissed PCNs.

That is potentially significant because we may now have grounds to advance an argument based on issue estoppel.

Issue estoppel arises where an issue has already been conclusively determined between the same parties in earlier proceedings. Although this claim concerns a different vehicle and a separate PCN, UKCPM may be prevented from reopening an issue that was necessarily decided in the earlier case.

If District Judge Ross determined that the particular location was outside UKCPM's authorised enforcement boundary, and the contractual arrangements have not changed, there is a credible argument that UKCPM should not be permitted to relitigate that same issue.

However, there is a distinction we need to establish. The present PCN alleges "Not Displaying a Valid Permit", whereas your account of the earlier judgment also refers to the prohibition on parking on access roads or roadways. We need to distinguish between a finding that UKCPM lacked enforcement authority over that location altogether and a narrower finding that the access-road prohibition simply did not apply. The former would make an issue-estoppel argument considerably stronger.

There is also the separate question of unreasonable claim-splitting. UKCPM already knew about this March 2025 PCN when it commenced the earlier proceedings in July 2025, yet chose to issue a further claim against the same defendant at the same residential development. That may support an additional argument concerning oppressive litigation and abuse of process under the principles of Henderson v Henderson.

We already have the court's written judgment confirming that only £100 of the original £300 in parking charges was awarded, together with your first-hand account of the Judge's reasons for dismissing the other two PCNs. That is a substantial evidential basis for raising the earlier decision.

A transcript of the Judge's oral reasons would undoubtedly strengthen an issue-estoppel argument, because the written order does not expressly record the enforcement-boundary findings. However, transcripts must ordinarily be paid for, and the expense could be disproportionate to a claim of this value.

Importantly, even if the present claim were dismissed on the grounds of issue estoppel, you would not automatically recover the cost of obtaining a transcript. Small-claims costs are restricted by CPR 27.14. Although the court can award additional costs where a party has behaved unreasonably, merely losing a claim, even on an estoppel argument, does not automatically establish unreasonable conduct.

If UKCPM continued pursuing the claim despite being clearly informed of a binding earlier determination concerning the same enforcement boundary, that could strengthen an application for unreasonable-behaviour costs under CPR 27.14(2)(g). However, recovery would remain at the Judge's discretion, and I would not incur transcription expenses on the assumption that BW Legal would ultimately have to reimburse them.

My preference is therefore to rely initially on the existing court order, your account of the hearing and the evidence identifying the precise parking location. If the wording of the earlier oral judgment becomes decisive and UKCPM disputes your account, we can reconsider whether obtaining a transcript of the judgment reasons alone, rather than the entire hearing, would be proportionate.

For now, BW Legal remains subject to the unless order requiring amended Particulars of Claim by 4pm on 28 October 2026. I expect they will attempt to comply, but if they fail, the claim will be struck out automatically unless the court subsequently grants relief.

If amended Particulars are served, we will examine them alongside the earlier judgment, enforcement-boundary evidence, tenancy agreement, signage, incorrect postcode and PoFA defects before preparing the amended defence.

As you will be abroad, please arrange for someone to check your post. BW Legal is not necessarily obliged to serve the amended Particulars by email, and the court has allowed only 14 days from service for your amended defence.

For now, do not spend money on a transcript or make a separate application. We have enough to preserve the issue-estoppel argument, and the immediate priority is seeing whether BW Legal complies with the unless order.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#43
Hello,

Apologies for leaving this until the last minute - I have been out of the country for the past two weeks.

They served this amended PoC via letter dated 23/10/2026. It seems like the usual copy and paste splurge. I did note they said that under "Consideration" that the vehicle was parked in a private car park which isn't really the case. Further when  referring back to our last case where the vehicle was parked on an off road space - which is outside of their enforcement boundary - they have conveniently omitted the "no parking on Access roads/roadways"  sentence from their PoC section 6..

I haven't scanned them but they also added a N9A N9B and N9C form to the paperback. Haven't come across these before.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1...I-JbT63dTp
#44
@Barbudaprince, you have left me with ver little time to tr and get the defence ready. I need to know the date of the postmark on the envelope that their further PoC arrived. This is crucial.

Assuming they were posted on the same day as they are dated (23 October), without evidence to the contrary, your defence is due no later than Monday 9 November. That leaves me very little time to study the PoC and construct the defence.

I am travelling all day Sunday and will be 5 time zones west from then for the next 2 weeeks. That leaves me only today to prepare the defence unless you can show the postmark on the envelope.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#45
Yes post mark says 23rd October 2026.
#46
@Barbudaprince, I have now reviewed the amended Particulars, including BW Legal's assertions concerning the tenancy, signage, consideration, keeper liability and additional recovery costs. You can disregard the enclosed N9A, N9B and acknowledgment-of-service forms. These are standard response forms and are unnecessary because you have already defended the claim. The Judge's order requires an amended defence, not another acknowledgment or response pack.

The defence below is intended to stand on its own, with the factual detail, photographs, previous court order and supporting authorities that will be developed subsequently in the Witness Statement. It also preserves the option of inviting the court to strike out the claim without a further substantive hearing.

I am making the earlier judicial determination concerning UKCPM's enforcement boundary the principal defence point, followed by the Claimant's lack of standing, absence of keeper liability under PoFA, defective identification of the relevant land and failure to establish a contract.

One qualification is important: the previous written judgment does not record the Judge's reasons, so issue estoppel must be pleaded on the basis of the defendant's first-hand account of the findings, rather than suggesting those findings appear expressly in the order.

Quote:
IN THE COUNTY COURT AT BRENTFORD
Claim No.: [claim number]

Between

UK Car Park Management Ltd
Claimant
-and-

[Defendants full name]
Defendant

AMENDED DEFENCE

1. The Defendant denies the claim in its entirety. No contract, breach, liability or debt is admitted. The Defendant was the registered keeper of the vehicle but has not identified the driver.

PREVIOUS JUDICIAL DETERMINATION – ISSUE ESTOPPEL

2. The Claimant previously pursued the Defendant in separate proceedings at Brentford County Court, issued on 18 July 2025, concerning three parking charges at the same residential development under the same parking scheme. On 27 August 2026, District Judge Ross awarded judgment for one £100 charge only, plus costs. The Defendant attended that hearing and confirms that the other two charges were dismissed following the Judge's finding that the vehicles were parked outside the Claimant's enforcement boundary and not on access roads or roadways as defined by the signage.

3. The vehicle in the present proceedings was parked in precisely the same location as the vehicles involved in those two dismissed charges. The Defendant avers that the earlier determination of the Claimant's enforcement boundary was a material and necessary finding between the same parties. Insofar as that determination established the Claimant's lack of enforcement authority over the relevant area, the Claimant is estopped from relitigating that issue. The Defendant relies upon the doctrine of issue estoppel and invites the Court to dismiss the claim accordingly.

ABUSE OF PROCESS – FRAGMENTED LITIGATION

4. The Claimant knew, or ought to have known, of the present PCN dated 20 March 2025 when it commenced the earlier proceedings on 18 July 2025. Nevertheless, represented by the same solicitors, it chose to issue separate proceedings against the same Defendant concerning the same residential parking regime. The Defendant avers that this unnecessary fragmentation, particularly following the earlier judicial determination concerning the same parking location, is oppressive and risks inconsistent judgments. The Defendant relies upon the principles established in Henderson v Henderson (1843) 3 Hare 100 and Johnson v Gore Wood & Co [2000] UKHL 65, and invites the Court to consider strike-out under CPR 3.4(2)(b).

NO PROVEN LANDOWNER AUTHORITY

5. Paragraph 3 of the amended Particulars asserts that the Claimant is authorised by London & Quadrant Housing Trust to enforce parking terms. This is denied insofar as it relates to the precise location of the alleged contravention. The Claimant is put to strict proof of its contractual authority, the applicable enforcement boundary, the duration of that authority and its entitlement to issue charges and litigate in its own name. A general agreement to manage parking elsewhere within the development does not establish authority over the specific land concerned.

INCORRECT IDENTIFICATION OF THE RELEVANT LAND

6. Paragraph 2 of the amended Particulars identifies the alleged location as Wheatstone House, 650 Chiswick High Road, W4 5SA, described as a private car park. This is disputed. Royal Mail identifies the residential premises as Wheatstone House, 650–654 Chiswick High Road, London, W4 5BB. The Claimant has again used the incorrect postcode and has not identified the precise parking area or its boundaries. The vehicle was positioned on hard standing with a dropped kerb, not within a conventional marked parking bay. The Claimant is put to strict proof that this location falls within the land covered by its contractual enforcement authority.

7. The incorrect and inadequate identification of the land is additionally disputed under Schedule 4 paragraph 9(2)(a) of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 ("PoFA"), which requires the Notice to Keeper ("NtK") to specify the relevant land on which the vehicle was parked. The Defendant avers that the Claimant has failed to establish compliance with that statutory requirement.

NO KEEPER LIABILITY – DEFECTIVE PERIOD OF PARKING

8. The NtK fails to comply with PoFA Schedule 4 paragraph 9(2)(a), which expressly requires the period of parking to be specified. Instead, it states only that the relevant period was "the period immediately preceding the incident time stated above". This identifies no starting point, duration or ascertainable period. It is an undefined assertion rather than a specified period of parking. The Claimant cannot retrospectively remedy a defective statutory notice through amended Particulars or subsequent witness evidence.

9. The two photographs reproduced on the NtK appear to have been taken only seconds apart at approximately 06:06, whereas the alleged incident time is 06:17. Those photographs do not themselves establish continuous observation between those times or identify any actual period of parking. The Claimant is put to strict proof of the observation records and the period relied upon. The Defendant avers that the statutory conditions for transferring liability to the keeper have not been satisfied.

NO PRESUMPTION THAT THE KEEPER WAS DRIVING

10. Paragraph 14 of the amended Particulars asserts keeper liability because the Defendant did not provide the name and address of another driver. This misstates the statutory position. There is no general legal obligation upon a registered keeper to identify the driver, nor any presumption that the registered keeper was driving. The Claimant must establish either driver liability through evidence or strict compliance with all applicable PoFA requirements. Neither has been established. The Defendant relies upon Vehicle Control Services Ltd v Edward (2023), County Court appeal, case HOKF6C9C.

NO PROVEN CONTRACTUAL FORMATION

11. Paragraphs 5–9 of the amended Particulars assert that signage was sufficient and that the driver accepted a contractual licence by entering the alleged car park and remaining beyond a reasonable consideration period. These assertions are denied. The Claimant has not established that the signage applied to the precise location, that its terms were adequately communicated, or that the driver had sufficient opportunity to read, consider and accept them. The Claimant is put to strict proof of the signage's positioning, visibility, legibility and incorporation of the alleged £100 charge.

12. The Private Parking Single Code of Practice requires a consideration period, subject to the applicable circumstances, with a minimum of five minutes before a parking contract can ordinarily be treated as accepted. The Claimant has not pleaded when the consideration period began or ended, nor identified evidence that the driver was afforded the required opportunity before the alleged breach. The photographic evidence does not, by itself, establish such compliance.

RESIDENTIAL TENANCY AND PERMIT CONDITIONS

13. The Defendant is a residential tenant at Wheatstone House under a tenancy agreement with London & Quadrant Housing Trust. Clause 4.15 regulates parking, including designated parking areas, hard standing, dropped kerbs and permit schemes. Although the tenancy anticipates permit requirements where a scheme operates, it does not itself establish any contractual obligation to pay £100 to the Claimant. The Claimant is not a party to that tenancy and must independently establish its authority and the alleged contractual liability. The Defendant denies that the tenancy establishes the Claimant's asserted entitlement.

MISCHARACTERISATION OF THE ALLEGED BREACH

14. The PCN specifically alleges "Not Displaying a Valid Permit". The vehicle was not parked on an access road or roadway and was not obstructing vehicular or pedestrian access. The Claimant's signage separately prohibits parking on access roads and roadways, but paragraph 6 of the amended Particulars selectively reproduces only the permit-display requirement. The Defendant denies that the Claimant can establish an enforceable contractual obligation at a location previously determined to fall outside its enforcement boundary merely by relying upon the permit condition. The Claimant must establish that the term applied to this precise land.

UNRECOVERABLE ADDITIONAL COSTS

15. The Claimant seeks £100 plus £60 described as debt recovery costs. These additional costs are denied. PoFA Schedule 4 paragraph 4(5) limits recovery from a keeper under that statutory right to the unpaid parking charge specified in the NtK, namely £100. The Claimant cannot recover an additional £60 from the Defendant merely by asserting keeper liability.

16. The Claimant's reliance upon an indemnity provision, the industry Code of Practice and Vehicle Control Services Ltd v Percy (2021) does not establish that this Defendant agreed to the additional sum, that it was actually incurred, or that it is recoverable independently of the statutory keeper-liability provisions. The Defendant denies any contractual or other lawful entitlement to that enhancement and avers that its recovery would constitute impermissible double recovery. The Claimant is put to strict proof of its legal basis and actual expenditure.

DEFECTIVE PARTICULARS AND FAILURE TO ESTABLISH LIABILITY

17. The amended Particulars were served following the unless order made by District Judge Jenkins on 5 October 2026. Although more extensive than the original pleading, they continue to assert contractual authority over an inadequately identified location without identifying the enforcement boundary, rely upon an unsupported assertion of keeper liability and fail to address the earlier judicial determination concerning the same parking location. The Defendant maintains that the Claimant has failed to establish a legally sustainable basis for recovery.

CONCLUSION AND RELIEF SOUGHT

18. For the foregoing reasons, the Defendant denies that the Claimant has any enforceable cause of action against the Defendant. The Court is respectfully invited to strike out the claim under CPR 3.4(2)(a) and/or (b), insofar as the pleaded case discloses no reasonable grounds or constitutes an abuse of process, or alternatively to dismiss the claim upon determination of the issues. The Defendant reserves the right to seek costs pursuant to CPR 27.14(2)(g) if the Claimant's conduct is found to have been unreasonable.

STATEMENT OF TRUTH

I believe that the facts stated in this amended Defence are true. I understand that proceedings for contempt of court may be brought against anyone who makes, or causes to be made, a false statement in a document verified by a statement of truth without an honest belief in its truth.

Signed:


Date:

For procedural purposes, the amended defence must be filed with Brentford County Court and served on BW Legal in accordance with the order. It should not simply be entered into MCOL as though this were a new defence to the original claim. MCOL plays no part once the claim has been transferred to the defendants local county court.

The postmark of Friday 23 October 2026 confirms the posting date. Under CPR 6.26, assuming first-class post, deemed service was Monday 26 October. The 14-day deadline therefore expires on Monday 9 November 2026.

You now need to do the following:

1. Prepare the amended defence as a PDF with the full court heading, claim number, numbered paragraphs and a Statement of Truth signed by typing their full name.
2. Email it to the Brentford County Court civil filing address, as published in the HMCTS court directory, with the claim number and parties' names in the subject line.
3. Serve the same PDF on BW Legal. Email is appropriate provided BW Legal has indicated that it accepts service by email under CPR PD 6A; otherwise, use an authorised alternative.
4. Retain the sent emails, attachments and any acknowledgments as evidence of filing and service.

Under Practice Direction 5B, PDF attachments are permitted subject to the applicable email-filing requirements. The email must be received by the court before 4pm on Monday 9 November, not merely sent before that time. There is no fee for filing the amended defence pursuant to the Judge's order.

Given the short deadline, I advise submitting it today, Saturday 7 November, rather than risking a last-minute technical or administrative problem on Monday.

The defence should be sent directly to Brentford County Court, which is now managing these proceedings, once everything is ready. You will need to sign the Statement of Truth by typing your full name. Also make sure you replace the placeholders for your full name and the claim number.

Attach the amended defence as a PDF file to an email and send it to brentfordcountycourt@justice.gov.uk and CC disputeresolution@bwlegal.co.uk and yourself. If you have used the BW Legal portal at all for this claim, you can also serve the defence on them using that method as a back up.

Quote:Subject: Claim No. [NUMBER] – UK Car Park Management Ltd v [Defendant] – Amended Defence

Dear Sir or Madam,

Re: Claim No. [CLAIM NUMBER] – UK Car Park Management Ltd v [Defendant]

Please find attached the Defendant's Amended Defence in respect of the above claim, filed and served pursuant to paragraph 2 of the Order of District Judge Jenkins dated 5 October 2026.

The Claimant's solicitors, BW Legal, have been copied into this email for simultaneous service of the Amended Defence.

Please place the attached document on the court file.

Yours faithfully,

[Defendant's Full Name]
Defendant

Let me know once you have sent it and whether you received any auto acknowledgement response.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#47
Star 
You're a ⭐.

Have submitted this now..no acknowledgement emails as yet.

Thanks,


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Instant notice to keeper, no first letter PCN received? cringepcnskekw 9 695 11-14-2026, 10:08 PM
Last Post: cringepcnskekw
  PCN - received while vehicle was being loaded for 10 minutes. KHarHar 19 2,705 10-29-2026, 12:31 PM
Last Post: KHarHar
  Claim form received from two alleged contraventions 3 years ago - SMART PARKING JoeBloggs90 21 4,929 10-13-2026, 02:13 PM
Last Post: b789
  Received a PCN whilst outside of the country JParker 5 1,046 09-29-2026, 10:53 AM
Last Post: b789
  Received a HM Claim form, not sure what to do! Dreamscape 4 978 08-25-2026, 07:27 PM
Last Post: Dreamscape
  Letter Before Claim from Moorside Legal (on behalf of Parking Control Management UK) Snowynight 7 5,457 03-09-2026, 02:02 AM
Last Post: b789
  Parked outside marked bay, PCM. 3 LOC/LBC Received Vivd23 1 1,037 02-28-2026, 03:58 PM
Last Post: b789
  Received a PCN from MET at Stansted (or Gatwick)? b789 0 791 01-22-2026, 03:42 PM
Last Post: b789
  Received a PCN at an airport? b789 0 1,004 01-19-2026, 03:13 PM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)