Welcome to the forum, @
Naj458.
@
Brenda_R2 is essentially correct. ParkingEye (PE) has finally corrected the longstanding defect in its Notices to Keeper (NtKs), which previously failed to comply with paragraph 9(2)(e)(i) of Schedule 4 to the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).
Following its defeat in
ParkingEye v Ganash last year, PE has now added the remarkably simple sentence:
"...or alternatively, you as the Registered Keeper, are invited to pay the Parking Charge."
That was all that was required to address this particular defect, which PE had stubbornly failed to correct for years. Unfortunately, it means that the previously successful PoFA argument is no longer available against this particular NtK.
However, that certainly does not mean the charge is automatically enforceable or that you should pay it.
It is also important to understand that this is not a "
fine" or penalty imposed by any statutory authority. ParkingEye is a private company with no authority to issue fines. What you have received is simply a
speculative invoice alleging that the driver, whose identity is unknown to PE, breached the terms of a purported parking contract.
PE is attempting to recover that alleged contractual charge from you as the Registered Keeper by relying on PoFA. However, compliance with PoFA does not automatically establish that a valid contract existed, that its terms were breached or that the charge is enforceable. It merely provides a statutory mechanism through which PE may hold the Keeper liable for a charge that would otherwise be recoverable from the driver, provided all the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied.
From what we know so far, the vehicle allegedly exceeded the maximum permitted stay of two hours at Asda Batley by 15 minutes. Before advising on the best approach, we need a little more context.
Was the driver or any passenger a customer of Asda during that visit? If so, is there any evidence of purchases, such as a receipt, bank statement or transaction in the Asda app?
There are four plans of action you should follow, always in this order:
Plan A – Landowner cancellation. Complain directly to Asda and ask for the charge to be cancelled. The landowner, or whoever has authority over the car park, is ultimately responsible for contracting ParkingEye (PE) to manage it. A genuine customer complaint, particularly supported by evidence of purchases, is often the most effective route.
Plan B – Appeal to the operator. If Plan A fails, submit an appeal directly to ParkingEye. We will advise on the wording once we have the necessary background. Importantly, any appeal should be made
only as the Registered Keeper, without identifying the driver.
Plan C – Independent appeals service. If PE rejects the appeal, it should issue a POPLA verification code. POPLA is the supposedly "independent" appeals service used by operators belonging to the British Parking Association (BPA). We can then consider whether there are sufficiently strong grounds for a POPLA appeal.
Plan D – County Court. If all else fails, there is no obligation to pay merely because PE or POPLA rejects an appeal. The remaining course is to wait and see whether PE decides to issue a court claim. If it does, the claim can be defended. Ultimately, a County Court judge, rather than PE or its industry's appeals service, is the genuinely independent arbiter who determines whether any enforceable debt exists.
For now, concentrate on
Plan A and answer the question about whether anyone in the vehicle was an Asda customer. There is no need to rush into an appeal to PE before we establish the circumstances.