Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
PCN Civil Enforcement Spring Hall Medical Practice, Halifax
#28
@3Sh3roo. this is a fairly remarkable climbdown from CEL, but it still does not resolve the matter properly.

They have now expressly admitted that your appeal of 15 May was made within the appeal period. That admission destroys their later claim that it was "too late to appeal" and explains why they have now withdrawn both the £70 debt-recovery addition and the Letter Before Action.

However, they are still trying to avoid actually determining the appeal. Saying they "maintain that the Parking Charge Notice was correctly issued" while offering £60 to make the matter go away is not an acceptable substitute for an appeal decision. If that statement amounts to rejection of the appeal, PPSCoP 8.4.6 requires them to give you the option of paying or appealing to the relevant independent Appeals Service — POPLA.

If it is not a rejection, then the appeal remains outstanding.

The formal complaint also remains live. PPSCoP 11.2 required them to deal with the correspondence as a complaint AND also treat the challenge to the PCN as an appeal. Their admission that the appeal was timely does not dispose of the complaint about how they then ignored it, incorrectly declared it out of time, escalated the charge and issued an LoC.

So I would not pay the £60. I would send the following to their Legal Team and require them to stop playing procedural games: either uphold the appeal and cancel, or reject it properly and provide the POPLA code. They must also finally determine the complaint:

Quote:Dear Civil Enforcement Ltd Legal Team,

Thank you for your email. Your admissions are noted.

Civil Enforcement Ltd now expressly accepts that my appeal was received on 15 May 2026 and was made within the applicable appeal period. You have accordingly withdrawn the debt recovery fees and the Letter Before Action.

That confirms that your subsequent assertion that it was "too late to appeal", the escalation to £170 and the Letter Before Action were all pursued while a valid and timely appeal remained unresolved. However, your latest email still fails to determine that appeal properly.

You state that Civil Enforcement Ltd "maintain[s] that the Parking Charge Notice was correctly issued". If that is your decision to reject the appeal, then PPSSCoP clause 8.4.6 requires you to provide the appellant with the option of either paying the parking charge or appealing the decision to the relevant independent Appeals Service. In this case, that means POPLA.

Accordingly, provide the POPLA verification code.

If your statement is not intended to constitute rejection of the appeal, then the appeal remains outstanding and must now be determined.

Your offer to accept £60 in "full and final settlement" is irrelevant to that obligation. It is not an appeal decision and it is not a substitute for the independent appeal to which I am entitled if you reject my appeal.

The formal complaint also remains outstanding. PPSCoP clause 11.2 required Civil Enforcement Ltd to deal with that correspondence as a complaint AND also treat the challenge to the PCN as an appeal. Your belated admission that the appeal was valid and timely does not dispose of the complaint concerning your subsequent mishandling of it, including incorrectly declaring it out of time, escalating the charge and issuing a Letter Before Action.

The position is therefore straightforward. Please now:

1. determine the appeal and either cancel the PCN or, if rejected, provide a valid POPLA verification code; and
2. provide your substantive final response to the formal complaint.

I will not be paying £60 simply because Civil Enforcement Ltd has finally acknowledged, five months later, that the appeal it previously claimed was out of time was in fact lodged correctly and on time.

Yours faithfully,

[Registered keeper]

The key point is that CEL cannot invent a third outcome of "we reject your position but will take £60 if you go away." Under the current PPSSCoP, rejection triggers access to the independent Appeals Service, POPLA.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain


Messages In This Thread
RE: PCN Civil Enforcement Spring Hall Medical Practice, Halifax - by b789 - 10-22-2026, 04:23 PM

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Debt Recovery Plus APCOA Broad Street, Halifax samh47 5 594 10-28-2026, 09:50 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN APCOA Broad Street Plaza, Halifax 3Sh3roo 4 1,007 07-29-2026, 05:00 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN Broadway Retail Park, Halifax 3Sh3roo 2 700 07-14-2026, 11:02 PM
Last Post: 3Sh3roo
  Help needed with Civil Enforcement Ltd CCJ claim Arbitration 8 2,641 06-13-2026, 03:07 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN Excel Crossley Retail Park, Halifax 3Sh3roo 19 6,503 04-02-2026, 06:55 PM
Last Post: b789
  Re: PCN from 'Civil Enforcement Ltd' badrav 13 5,615 02-19-2026, 12:14 PM
Last Post: badrav
Information ParkingEye, Harrow Hall, Langley b789 1 1,137 01-24-2026, 10:24 AM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)