Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
PPS pcn, whilst delivering parcels for amazon.
#15
PPS has provided some evidence.
“Dear POPLA Assessor, We write on behalf of Private Parking Solutions (London) Ltd in response to the appeal concerning Parking Charge (pc number) , issued to vehicle (reg) at Donnington House, 2A Sutton Court Road, Sutton, SM1 4SY, following the parking event on 1 October 2026 at approximately 20:29. The Parking Charge was issued for “Not Clearly Displaying a Valid Permit”, in accordance with the terms and conditions displayed at the site. The operator maintains that the photographic evidence, signage, site map and landowner agreement establish that the vehicle was parked on controlled private land without a clearly displayed valid permit. The signage identifies the site as private land restricted to permit holders and requires a valid parking permit to be clearly displayed on the front windscreen. It also instructs drivers to park within marked bays and prohibits parking on yellow lines, footpaths or in a manner causing obstruction. The £100 Parking Charge, reduced to £60 if paid within 14 days, is clearly displayed. The terms also state, “DO NOT PARK HERE UNLESS YOU AGREE TO THE TERMS & CONDITIONS DISPLAYED.” The entrance photograph shows a prominently positioned “PRIVATE LAND – PERMIT HOLDERS ONLY” sign, with further signs installed along the boundary wall. The site map identifies the managed area and relevant sign positions. These materials demonstrate how the parking restrictions are communicated to motorists. The contemporaneous photographs show vehicle (reg) parked beside the wall within the controlled area. The first photograph is timestamped 20:22:02 and the last 20:28:52, an interval of 6 minutes and 50 seconds. The vehicle remains in the same position in the first and final images. Photographs of the windscreen show a circular item described as a resident permit, but do not establish that a valid PPS permit for this location was clearly displayed. The supplied example PPS permit identifies the site and includes validity fields. The displayed circular item is not evidence that the vehicle complied with the requirement to display a valid permit accepted at Donnington House. The operator therefore maintains that the recorded reason for issue is supported by the photographic evidence. The appellant states that the vehicle was being used for Amazon deliveries and has supplied an Amazon delivery block confirmation covering 19:45 to 22:15 on 1 October 2026. The operator acknowledges that this document supports the appellant's account of being scheduled for courier work. However, it does not identify Donnington House as a delivery destination, confirm a delivery at the location during the observation period or establish permission to park without a valid permit. A courier booking alone does not demonstrate an exemption from the conditions applicable to this private land. The appellant refers to Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd and argues that temporary loading or unloading should be distinguished from parking. The operator acknowledges that the circumstances of an actual delivery may be relevant to that distinction. Nevertheless, the appellant's block confirmation does not establish what activity was taking place at Donnington House during the observed period. The evidence available to the operator shows a vehicle remaining in the same position for 6 minutes and 50 seconds without a clearly displayed valid site permit. No site-specific delivery record or permission has been provided. The operator therefore maintains that the appellant has not established that the observed parking was authorised or exempt from the displayed terms. The landowner agreement supplied for Donnington House authorises Private Parking Solutions (London) Ltd to manage parking and pursue charges for breaches of the advertised restrictions. It expressly requires a valid PPS permit to be displayed facing upwards on the windscreen and does not provide a general exemption for Amazon couriers or commercial delivery drivers. The agreement was signed in December 2023 and provides for continuation subject to its termination provisions. The operator relies upon the agreement and site map to establish its authority over the relevant area on the date of the parking event. The appellant's request for further evidence of a courier exemption does not establish that any such exemption existed. The appellant questions whether permit-holder signage can create a contract with an unauthorised motorist. The operator submits that the sign must be read as a whole. It identifies the conditions of parking, the permit requirement and the £100 charge arising from non-compliance. It also explains that parking on the private land carries contractual liability for unauthorised parking and instructs drivers not to park unless they agree with the displayed terms. The operator maintains that the signage communicates the contractual conditions and the consequences of leaving a vehicle parked without meeting them. The displayed contact details also provide a means to enquire about authorisation before parking. The appellant raises the visibility of the signs at night. The contemporaneous photograph taken at 20:28:52 shows a terms-and-conditions sign installed on the wall near the vehicle, and a separate close photograph taken at 20:28:52 records its wording. The additional entrance photograph demonstrates the prominent positioning of the permit-holders-only sign and further signs along the wall, although that photograph was taken in daylight. The operator relies on the combined evidence of the signs' positions, the site map and the contemporaneous nighttime images; it does not claim that the daylight entrance photograph was taken during the parking event. The appellant disputes the consideration period. The purpose of that period is to give a motorist sufficient opportunity to find, read and understand the terms and decide whether to remain. The photographs establish that the vehicle remained parked in the same position for 6 minutes and 50 seconds, and do not show the driver examining the signage during the photographed moments. The operator submits that this evidence is consistent with an established parking event rather than a driver simply reading the terms. It is not claimed that the photographs establish the driver's whereabouts throughout the entire interval. The operator maintains that motorists must ensure that the displayed permit requirements are met when choosing to leave their vehicles parked. The appellant appeals as the registered keeper and has not identified the driver. The operator acknowledges that there is no presumption that the keeper was driving and no general obligation to name the driver. The postal notice invited the keeper to provide the driver's name and current address for service. Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 permits recovery of an unpaid parking charge from a keeper where the driver is not identified only if the applicable statutory conditions have been satisfied. The operator relies upon the notice issued on 5 October 2026, within 14 days of the event, and the accompanying evidence. The notice identifies the vehicle, location, incident date, charge and alleged breach, and contains a warning concerning potential keeper liability. The appellant specifically challenges paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4, arguing that the notice describes the period of parking only as the period immediately preceding the incident time of 20:29. The operator submits the timestamped photographs and observation records to establish the period actually observed and the circumstances of the alleged breach. The photographic record runs from 20:22:02 to 20:28:52. The operator recognises that these records do not alter the wording of the original notice and that any transfer of liability to the keeper remains dependent upon compliance with the statutory requirement to specify the period of parking. The appellant also raises paragraph 9(2)(e); the notice invites the keeper, if not the driver, to provide the driver's name and current address for service and pass the notice to that person. The operator relies upon the notice as issued for consideration of its statutory wording. The appellant also refers to a later Government parking code. The operator notes that any requirements introduced after 1 October 2026 cannot be applied retrospectively to this event. The parking conditions and relevant legal and industry requirements applicable on the incident date remain the basis of the operator's position. The internal appeal was considered and rejected by correspondence dated 21 October 2026, which identified the permit requirement and the reason for issuing the Parking Charge. The appellant's submitted evidence, including the Amazon delivery block confirmation and copies of the notice and correspondence, does not demonstrate that a valid site permit was displayed or that the landholder had authorised this vehicle to park without one. In conclusion, Private Parking Solutions (London) Ltd maintains that the Parking Charge was issued for a breach of the clearly displayed permit requirement. The vehicle was photographed parked within the controlled area without a clearly displayed valid PPS permit, the signage identifies the applicable conditions and charge, and the landowner agreement supports the operator's authority. The Amazon block confirmation does not establish a site-specific delivery or exemption. The operator respectfully requests that the appeal be refused and the Parking Charge upheld, subject to the applicable statutory requirements governing any recovery from the registered keeper.”

https://prodapi.popla.co.uk/appeal/GetDo...ntract.pdf

This is the evidence they have provided alongside some additional photos of the vehicle which I have already shown. 
What comments shall i make?


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
                   


Messages In This Thread
RE: PPS pcn, whilst delivering parcels for amazon. - by zyno - 10-24-2026, 11:02 AM

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  UKPC ticket whilst driver was delivering parcels on moat lane, nine elms. zyno 15 1,324 11-20-2026, 05:11 PM
Last Post: b789
  got this private parking PCN due to delivering.. cringepcnskekw 3 511 10-30-2026, 11:22 AM
Last Post: b789
  Received a PCN whilst outside of the country JParker 5 1,045 09-29-2026, 10:53 AM
Last Post: b789
  UKPC PCN while delivering for Amazon Flex – POPLA advice needed ibadusaf 7 2,113 08-08-2026, 04:04 PM
Last Post: b789
  LPS Ltd - PCN - Private Access Road - Delivering On Site & Vehicle Breakdown TheParkingmeister 27 8,674 05-26-2026, 04:32 PM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)