10-31-2026, 04:23 PM
(10-31-2026, 12:46 PM)Naj458 Wrote: Hello again, and thanks for the detailed response @b789 and warm welcome! Thanks also to @Brenda_R2 for your help with this, I really appreciate it.
Unfortunately, there was no visit to Asda. The car was parked there in order to visit a restaurant nearby. The Tesco opposite has shared parking for several other shops, so the driver assumed it would be fine to park at Asda as well, without realising how long they’d be there or that it could result in a fine. No Asda customer.
Let me see if I've understood this correctly.
Your defence is:
"I wasn't an Asda customer, I had no intention of being an Asda customer, I parked on Asda's land for three hours while spending money somewhere else, I didn't check the signs, and I just assumed the rules didn't apply because Tesco has a different arrangement."
That's not a defence. That's practically the parking company's witness statement.
You've essentially confessed to every element of their claim and then added helpful context.
Imagine standing before a judge and saying:
"I didn't buy a ticket for the train because the bus company across the road lets people travel without one."
That's the level of legal firepower we're working with here.
Private parking cases are won by identifying failures in signage, contractual wording, landowner authority, POFA compliance, grace periods, evidence deficiencies, or procedural errors.
They're generally not won by:
"Yes, I did exactly what they say I did, but I mistakenly thought someone else's car park worked the same way."
At the moment your appeal appears to consist of a detailed explanation of why the charge was correctly issued.
If you want help, learned members of this forum can certainly look for technical or legal arguments. But as a defence, "I parked in Asda for three hours while visiting a restaurant and wasn't an Asda customer" is roughly equivalent to contesting a speeding ticket with "I was doing 50 in a 30 but thought the limit was only advisory."
Pay the PCN before the charge escalates massively.

