11-09-2026, 04:49 PM
@CD!, this is an interesting development, and DCB Legal appear to have created another problem for themselves.
The court order expressly required the claimant to file and serve properly particularised PoC by Friday 23 October 2026. You have now received amended PoC dated Friday 6 November, exactly two weeks after that deadline.
Even if they filed something with the court before 23 October, the order required them to serve it on you by that date as well. On the information available, they have failed to comply with the judge's directions.
There is also the question of whether you ever agreed in writing to accept formal service of court documents by email. If not, their email may not constitute valid service under CPR Practice Direction 6A, paragraph 4.1.
I would not read too much into the timing of the email arriving shortly after your telephone call. It could simply be a coincidence. There is no evidence that anyone at the court contacted DCB Legal.
The important point is that the judge's order contains no automatic strike-out provision. However, CPR 3.4(2)(c) gives the court the power to strike out a claim where a party has failed to comply with a court order.
Before writing to the court, I want to examine the amended PoC in detail. We need to establish whether they have actually remedied the deficiencies identified in your original defence, or whether they have simply produced another inadequate set of particulars.
We must also protect your position regarding the 14-day deadline for submitting a further defence. If the email constituted valid service before 4.30 pm on Friday 6 November, that deadline would be Friday 20 November. If sent after 4.30 pm, deemed service would ordinarily be Monday 9 November, making the deadline Monday 23 November.
My preference is to prepare a robust further defence if necessary, while separately drawing the claimant's non-compliance with the court order to the judge's attention and inviting the court to consider striking out the claim.
I remain confident that DCB Legal will eventually discontinue, but we must continue to comply with our own obligations until that happens.
I will get back to you here after I've had a chance to go through their further PoC.
The court order expressly required the claimant to file and serve properly particularised PoC by Friday 23 October 2026. You have now received amended PoC dated Friday 6 November, exactly two weeks after that deadline.
Even if they filed something with the court before 23 October, the order required them to serve it on you by that date as well. On the information available, they have failed to comply with the judge's directions.
There is also the question of whether you ever agreed in writing to accept formal service of court documents by email. If not, their email may not constitute valid service under CPR Practice Direction 6A, paragraph 4.1.
I would not read too much into the timing of the email arriving shortly after your telephone call. It could simply be a coincidence. There is no evidence that anyone at the court contacted DCB Legal.
The important point is that the judge's order contains no automatic strike-out provision. However, CPR 3.4(2)(c) gives the court the power to strike out a claim where a party has failed to comply with a court order.
Before writing to the court, I want to examine the amended PoC in detail. We need to establish whether they have actually remedied the deficiencies identified in your original defence, or whether they have simply produced another inadequate set of particulars.
We must also protect your position regarding the 14-day deadline for submitting a further defence. If the email constituted valid service before 4.30 pm on Friday 6 November, that deadline would be Friday 20 November. If sent after 4.30 pm, deemed service would ordinarily be Monday 9 November, making the deadline Monday 23 November.
My preference is to prepare a robust further defence if necessary, while separately drawing the claimant's non-compliance with the court order to the judge's attention and inviting the court to consider striking out the claim.
I remain confident that DCB Legal will eventually discontinue, but we must continue to comply with our own obligations until that happens.
I will get back to you here after I've had a chance to go through their further PoC.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain

