11-09-2026, 05:48 PM
@CD!, you must send the following to the court manager at Enquiries.kingston.countycourt@justice.gov.uk and CC DCB Legal and yourself:
I will get back to you with a separate formal complaint to HMCTS which will not be able to be tampered with if there is someone at the court who is informing DCB Legal without the necessary authorisation.
Quote:FOR THE ATTENTION OF THE COURT MANAGER – KINGSTON-UPON-THAMES COUNTY COURT
Formal Complaint and Request for Referral to District Judge Hartley
Claim Number: N7KF070Q
Claimant: MET Parking Services Ltd
Defendant: Christopher Davis
Dear Sir or Madam,
I am the Defendant in these proceedings, acting as a litigant in person. I write to make a formal complaint requiring investigation by the Court Manager into circumstances suggesting possible procedural impropriety, and to request that the Claimant's failure to comply with the Order of District Judge Hartley dated 22 September 2026 be referred urgently to the District Judge for consideration of strike-out under CPR 3.4(2)(c).
1. Failure to comply with the Court Order
The Order expressly required the Claimant to "by 23 October 2026 file and serve a properly particularised particulars of claim."
That deadline passed without the Claimant serving any amended Particulars of Claim upon me. By Friday 6 November 2026, a full 14 days after the court-ordered deadline, I had received nothing whatsoever from the Claimant or its solicitors.
In the absence of any communication, and given the Claimant's apparent failure to comply with the Order, I telephoned the Court on Friday 6 November specifically to establish whether the Claimant had filed the required documents and, crucially, whether the claim remained live or had been struck out following the Claimant's failure to comply with the Court's directions.
I spoke to a member of the centralised court administration service, who checked the case management system and informed me that there was no recorded update. I was advised that updates could take up to ten weeks to appear and that I should await further correspondence.
2. Highly concerning sequence of events following my enquiry
Approximately TWO HOURS after making that telephone enquiry, I unexpectedly received an email from DCB Legal Ltd attaching purported Amended Particulars of Claim.
The document was signed by a DCB Legal paralegal, Jessica Hammond, and expressly dated 6 November 2026 — the very same day as my enquiry to the Court, and exactly 14 days after the deadline imposed by District Judge Hartley.
This is not simply a case of documents arriving late in the post or being delayed in the Court's administrative system.
The Amended Particulars of Claim bear a Statement of Truth signed and dated 6 November 2026. This is particularly significant because the document, in its signed and verified form, demonstrably postdates the court-ordered deadline by 14 days. The Claimant has therefore not merely served the document late; it has produced a document whose own date raises serious questions about when the amended pleadings were actually prepared and whether there was any genuine attempt to comply with the Court's Order by 23 October 2026.
The sequence of events is particularly troubling:
• The Claimant failed to serve amended Particulars of Claim by 23 October 2026.
• Nothing was received during the following 14 days.
• On 6 November, I contacted the Court specifically to enquire about that failure and whether the claim remained live.
• Approximately two hours later, DCB Legal emailed amended Particulars of Claim bearing a Statement of Truth signed and dated 6 November 2026.
The extraordinary timing raises a legitimate and serious question as to whether DCB Legal were alerted to my enquiry and their outstanding non-compliance, prompting the hurried preparation and service of documents which should have been filed and served two weeks earlier.
I fully appreciate that I cannot establish, from the information presently available, whether any communication occurred between court staff and the Claimant's representatives following my telephone call.
Nevertheless, the circumstances are sufficiently unusual that I believe they warrant the Court's attention and appropriate enquiries.
If a member of court staff did contact DCB Legal following my enquiry, particularly to alert them to their failure to comply with the Order, I would respectfully ask the Court to examine whether that communication was appropriate, properly recorded and consistent with the requirement that proceedings be conducted fairly and transparently.
My concern is that the Claimant may have been afforded an opportunity to remedy its procedural default following my enquiry, without any corresponding notification to me or judicial authorisation extending the deadline.
If that occurred, it would raise serious questions about procedural fairness and potentially improper conduct. I do not suggest that any unlawful disclosure or misconduct has been established, but I respectfully submit that the circumstances should not simply be dismissed as an administrative coincidence without enquiry.
I therefore request confirmation of whether any communication was made to DCB Legal or the Claimant following my telephone enquiry on 6 November 2026 and, if so, when, by whom and for what purpose.
I also request that the Court preserve any available administrative records or telephone contact notes relating to my enquiry of 6 November 2026, together with any subsequent communications concerning this claim, pending consideration of this complaint.
3. Continuing deficiencies in the amended Particulars of Claim
Notwithstanding the Claimant's failure to comply with the deadline, the purported amended Particulars of Claim still contain material deficiencies.
Of particular concern is paragraph 11, in which the Claimant now asserts that I was the driver of the vehicle "on the balance of probabilities that they would have otherwise nominated a driver."
The Claimant has provided no pleaded factual basis establishing that I was driving. Instead, it attempts to infer driver identity from the registered keeper's failure to nominate another person, notwithstanding the absence of any legal presumption that a registered keeper was the driver.
Furthermore, the Claimant identifies the alleged contravention as an "Overstay" but fails to particularise the actual period of parking, the duration of the alleged overstay, or the factual basis upon which the alleged contractual breach is established.
Having already been given an opportunity to correct its original defective pleadings, the Claimant has therefore submitted a late document which continues to leave material aspects of its case inadequately particularised.
4. Request for judicial consideration and strike-out
I respectfully submit that the Claimant's conduct should be considered in the context of the overriding objective under CPR 1.1.
The Claimant is professionally represented by solicitors who routinely conduct this category of litigation. It cannot reasonably be suggested that compliance with a clearly expressed court deadline was beyond their understanding.
The Claimant has failed to comply with the Court's express directions and has provided no explanation for that failure or any indication that permission was obtained to serve amended pleadings after the deadline.
I therefore respectfully invite District Judge Hartley to exercise the Court's own-initiative powers under CPR 3.3 and strike out the claim pursuant to CPR 3.4(2)(b) and/or (c), on the grounds that the Claimant has failed to comply with the Court's express directions and that the circumstances may disclose an abuse of the Court's process.
I also ask the Court to consider whether the circumstances surrounding the production of the amended Particulars of Claim warrant further investigation into possible procedural impropriety or abuse of process.
In particular, I respectfully request that the Court:
1. Confirm whether the Claimant filed any amended Particulars of Claim by 23 October 2026 and, if not, the actual date of filing.
2. Establish whether any communication occurred between court staff and the Claimant or DCB Legal following my telephone enquiry on 6 November 2026.
3. Require the Claimant to explain its failure to comply with the deadline and the circumstances in which the amended Particulars of Claim came to be signed and served on 6 November 2026.
4. Consider striking out the claim under CPR 3.4(2)(b) and/or (c), without requiring a further defence to pleadings served in breach of the Court's directions.
I respectfully request that this correspondence, together with the attached Amended Particulars of Claim dated 6 November 2026, be placed before District Judge Hartley for consideration.
Pending any further direction, I reserve my position in respect of the amended pleadings and will comply with the existing defence deadline unless the Court orders otherwise.
As a litigant in person, I am entitled to expect that judicial directions will be observed and that any failure by a professionally represented claimant to comply with those directions will receive appropriate judicial scrutiny.
I would be grateful for acknowledgement of receipt, confirmation that this complaint has been referred to the Court Manager for investigation, and confirmation that the procedural issues have been referred to District Judge Hartley.
This email has been copied to DCB Legal Ltd, the Claimant's solicitors, in accordance with CPR 39.8.
Yours faithfully,
Christopher Davis
Defendant, Litigant in Person
Cc: DCB Legal Ltd – Solicitors for the Claimant
Attachments:
1. Court Order dated 22 September 2026
2. Amended Particulars of Claim signed and dated 6 November 2026
I will get back to you with a separate formal complaint to HMCTS which will not be able to be tampered with if there is someone at the court who is informing DCB Legal without the necessary authorisation.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain

