Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
PCN - Overstay - 22/12/24 @ Southgate Park, Stansted
#26
@CD!, I also advise you to submit the following formal complaint to HMCTS. The following complaint concentrates on possible improper communication by HMCTS staff, rather than asking HMCTS to determine the claim, which remains a judicial matter. Submit it through their portal at:

https://hmcts-complaint-form-eng.form.se...ce.gov.uk/

Use the following to copy and paste into the three relevant text boxes:

Quote:1. What is your complaint about?

Quote:I wish to make a formal complaint concerning possible procedural impropriety involving HMCTS court administration staff in connection with an ongoing County Court claim, N7KF070Q – MET Parking Services Ltd v Christopher Davis, at Kingston-upon-Thames County Court.

By an Order dated 22 September 2026, District Judge Hartley directed the Claimant to file and serve properly particularised Particulars of Claim by 23 October 2026.

The Claimant failed to serve those documents by the deadline. By Friday 6 November 2026, a full 14 days later, I had received nothing.

On that date, I telephoned the court using the telephone number on the Order, specifically to establish whether the Claimant had complied with the judge's directions and whether the claim remained live or had been struck out.

I spoke to a member of the centralised court administration service, who checked the case management system and informed me that no update was recorded. I was advised that updates could take up to ten weeks to appear.

Approximately TWO HOURS after that telephone enquiry, I unexpectedly received an email from the Claimant's solicitors, DCB Legal Ltd, attaching purported Amended Particulars of Claim.

Crucially, those documents were signed by a DCB Legal paralegal, Jessica Hammond, and dated 6 November 2026 — the very day of my telephone enquiry and exactly 14 days after the court-ordered deadline.

This was not a case of documents having been prepared and served before the deadline but subsequently delayed in transit. The document's own Statement of Truth bears a date two weeks after the deadline.

The extraordinary timing raises a serious concern that someone within HMCTS may have contacted DCB Legal following my enquiry, alerting them to their failure to comply with the Court Order and prompting the preparation and immediate service of the overdue documents.

I recognise that I do not currently possess evidence establishing that such communication occurred. However, the sequence of events is sufficiently unusual to warrant a formal investigation.

If information arising from my enquiry was communicated to the Claimant's solicitors, particularly for the purpose of alerting them to their procedural default, this would raise serious questions about the impartiality of court administration, procedural fairness and whether one party was afforded an inappropriate advantage.

My complaint concerns the possibility of improper administrative conduct and the handling of information obtained during my telephone enquiry. I am not asking HMCTS to interfere with any judicial decision.

2. How has this affected you?

Quote:I am a litigant in person defending a claim brought by a professionally represented parking company.

I am entitled to expect that the Court's directions will be administered impartially and that both parties will be treated equally, consistently with the overriding objective under CPR 1.1.

The Claimant was expressly required to comply with a deadline of 23 October 2026. Having received nothing by 6 November, I contacted the court in good faith to establish the procedural position and whether the claim remained live.

The fact that the Claimant's solicitors produced and served documents signed and dated that very day, approximately two hours after my enquiry, has seriously undermined my confidence in the fairness and transparency of the court's administrative processes.

If my enquiry resulted in the Claimant being alerted to its default and given an opportunity to remedy it without judicial authorisation or corresponding notification to me, I would have been placed at a significant procedural disadvantage.

The late documents also potentially require me to prepare a further defence, incurring additional time and effort despite the Claimant's failure to comply with the Court Order.

I am particularly concerned that, without an independent investigation, any inappropriate communication could remain undisclosed and the proceedings could continue without the circumstances being properly examined.

The overriding objective requires parties to be placed on an equal footing. Any administrative intervention which assists one party in remedying non-compliance with a judicial order, while withholding that information from the opposing party, would be fundamentally inconsistent with that principle.

3. What would you like HMCTS to do to resolve your complaint?

Quote:I request a formal investigation by HMCTS management independent of any staff member who may have been involved in the events of 6 November 2026.

Specifically, I request that HMCTS:

1. Identify the member of staff who handled my telephone enquiry on Friday 6 November 2026 and examine the relevant telephone records, call recordings, administrative notes and case-management records.
2. Establish whether any member of HMCTS staff contacted MET Parking Services Ltd or DCB Legal Ltd following my enquiry and, if so, identify when that communication occurred, who authorised it, what information was communicated and why.
3. Preserve all relevant records, including telephone recordings, electronic case-management entries, internal messages and any correspondence with the Claimant or its solicitors relating to my enquiry and the Court Order.
4. Confirm whether the amended Particulars of Claim were filed with the court, the actual date of filing and whether any application for an extension of time or relief from sanctions was received.
5. Investigate whether any communication, if established, was consistent with HMCTS policies concerning impartiality, confidentiality, procedural fairness and the proper administration of judicial directions.
6. Provide a substantive written response setting out the investigation's findings, including whether any communication occurred and, if so, what action HMCTS considers appropriate.

Given that the complaint potentially concerns the conduct of court administration staff, I specifically request that it not be investigated solely by any individual whose actions may be the subject of the complaint.

I also request that the complaint be formally logged, allocated a complaint reference and considered through the appropriate HMCTS management process.

I have separately brought the Claimant's failure to comply with the Court Order to the attention of Kingston-upon-Thames County Court and requested judicial consideration of strike-out under CPR 3.4(2)(b) and/or (c). That is a separate judicial matter.

This complaint concerns the integrity, impartiality and transparency of the administrative process and the possibility that the Claimant received an inappropriate procedural advantage following my telephone enquiry.

I expect HMCTS to investigate these concerns thoroughly rather than dismiss the extraordinary sequence of events as a coincidence without examining the available records.

The HMCTS complaints process addresses administrative handling rather than judicial decisions, and HMCTS states that it aims to respond within 10 working days.

Remind me in a few days to get the amended defence sorted if nothing further has been heard back from the court or DCB Legal.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain


Messages In This Thread
RE: PCN - Overstay - 22/12/24 @ Southgate Park, Stansted - by b789 - 11-09-2026, 06:06 PM

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  PCN - Premier Park - Aspects Leisure Park Bristol onFourWheels 9 1,143 10 hours ago
Last Post: b789
  GroupNexus retail park overstay MW02 11 533 11-20-2026, 05:30 PM
Last Post: b789
  Charge from UKPC, Maylands Avenue Retail Park therealrjp 2 300 11-01-2026, 04:33 PM
Last Post: therealrjp
  UKPC Worcester Blackpole McDonalds Car Park Ogrebear 34 7,947 10-29-2026, 10:47 PM
Last Post: Ogrebear
  Not parking fully in a bay UKPC LTD Valley Leisure Park crorydon Torenaga 42 11,841 10-16-2026, 02:05 PM
Last Post: Torenaga
  Group Nexus overstay at Roadchef Maidstone Services SamedayCourier 15 3,159 10-15-2026, 05:23 PM
Last Post: b789
  30 min overstay Tezzy 12 1,913 10-14-2026, 10:47 AM
Last Post: b789
  Chalon Way West Retail Park - ParkingEye billnit 9 1,172 10-09-2026, 03:14 PM
Last Post: billnit
Question PCN - UKPS - Dragon Retail Park, Cardiff onFourWheels 5 1,328 08-18-2026, 05:53 PM
Last Post: b789
  Ulverston Premier Inn Car Park L Bow 22 5,485 08-17-2026, 10:30 AM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)