11-16-2026, 04:18 PM
@Tortfeasor, good. If you are prepared to stand your ground, the unsuccessful POPLA appeal changes very little. POPLA’s decision is not binding upon you, and Horizon cannot rely upon it as proof of liability. If Horizon wants payment, it must ultimately prove its case before a judge on the evidence and the law.
A court should examine the issues afresh. Horizon would still need to establish keeper liability, including that the original NtK was actually posted within the statutory process. Producing a copy months later does not prove posting, particularly when the promised “case records” were absent, the issue dates conflict and the NtK was omitted from the SAR response.
The signage evidence would also be considered on its merits. Your nighttime photographs and footage directly address the conditions when the alleged contract was supposedly formed, whereas Horizon relied upon old daylight photographs. The continuing presence of the YourParkingSpace signs is also relevant because Horizon would have to explain how their offer of parking for more than three hours operates alongside its purported one-hour restriction. If the notices create genuinely different possible meanings, section 69 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 requires the meaning most favourable to the consumer to prevail.
Keep the latest ICO response and preserve all existing evidence. It may also be sensible to retain a dated record showing that the entrance sign remains illegible at night even after the tree has shed its leaves, but there is no need to keep revisiting the site or accumulating endless photographs.
For now, expect demands and powerless debt-recovery letters. File them in the bin and do not engage with powerless debt collectors. If Horizon or a solicitor sends a formal Letter of Claim, or if a County Court claim arrives, update the thread immediately and we will deal with it properly.
A court should examine the issues afresh. Horizon would still need to establish keeper liability, including that the original NtK was actually posted within the statutory process. Producing a copy months later does not prove posting, particularly when the promised “case records” were absent, the issue dates conflict and the NtK was omitted from the SAR response.
The signage evidence would also be considered on its merits. Your nighttime photographs and footage directly address the conditions when the alleged contract was supposedly formed, whereas Horizon relied upon old daylight photographs. The continuing presence of the YourParkingSpace signs is also relevant because Horizon would have to explain how their offer of parking for more than three hours operates alongside its purported one-hour restriction. If the notices create genuinely different possible meanings, section 69 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 requires the meaning most favourable to the consumer to prevail.
Keep the latest ICO response and preserve all existing evidence. It may also be sensible to retain a dated record showing that the entrance sign remains illegible at night even after the tree has shed its leaves, but there is no need to keep revisiting the site or accumulating endless photographs.
For now, expect demands and powerless debt-recovery letters. File them in the bin and do not engage with powerless debt collectors. If Horizon or a solicitor sends a formal Letter of Claim, or if a County Court claim arrives, update the thread immediately and we will deal with it properly.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain

