Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
PCN Civil Enforcement Spring Hall Medical Practice, Halifax
#30
Thanks @3Sh3roo. The N1SDT Claim Form page containing the Particulars of Claim was all I needed to see.

You now have two procedural options.

If you are happy to submit the Defence below now, you do not need to file an Acknowledgment of Service (AoS) first. The claim was issued on 11 November 2026 and is deemed served on 16 November, so without an AoS the Defence must be filed no later than 4:00pm on Monday 30 November 2026.

Alternatively, if you want more time, file an AoS through MCOL before that deadline. Tick that you intend to defend all of the claim. Do not contest jurisdiction and do not enter anything purporting to be your Defence at that stage. Filing the AoS extends the Defence deadline to 4:00pm on Monday 14 December 2026.

There is no disadvantage in filing the AoS if you want the extra time. You do not then have to wait until 14 December; you can submit the Defence at any point before that deadline.

If you are ready to defend immediately, select the option to defend the whole claim and copy and paste the Defence below into the Defence box. Check carefully before submitting that the entire text has been accepted by the portal and keep a screenshot/confirmation of submission.

I do not recommend making a counterclaim.

A counterclaim is a separate legal claim by you against CEL. Their appalling handling of this PCN does not, by itself, automatically give rise to a freestanding cause of action for damages. A counterclaim would require a proper legal basis, evidence of recoverable loss or damage and payment of a court fee. It would also unnecessarily complicate what is otherwise a strong Defence. Importantly, if CEL later discontinued its own claim, a counterclaim would remain alive and you would then have to continue prosecuting it yourself.

That does not mean CEL's conduct is irrelevant. Quite the opposite.

If this proceeds on the small claims track, the normal rule is that legal costs are very restricted. However, CPR 27.14(2)(g) allows the court to award further costs where a party has behaved unreasonably. That is a discretionary award and the threshold is not automatic merely because CEL loses, but there is already material here which could support such an application.

CEL admitted that your 15 May appeal was timely; nevertheless told you it was too late; escalated the charge to £170; commenced debt recovery; issued a Letter Before Action; subsequently admitted its mistake and expressly withdrew the debt recovery fees and that Letter Before Action; failed to provide the POPLA opportunity following its rejection of the appeal; and has now issued proceedings claiming £170 again, notwithstanding its own Legal Team's express statement that the debt recovery fees had been withdrawn.

Keep every letter and email. Also start keeping a simple record of the time reasonably spent dealing with the litigation and any expenditure incurred. If CEL pursue this to a hearing and the court considers their conduct unreasonable, we can prepare a proper costs schedule and invite the judge to make an order under CPR 27.14(2)(g). No counterclaim is required to seek those costs.

For the Defence, remember that this is only the framework — the "hooks" on which the later Witness Statement and exhibits will hang. We do not need to prove everything or reproduce the entire correspondence history now.

Use the following Defence body:

Quote:1. The Defendant denies that the Claimant is entitled to the relief claimed, or at all. The Defendant was the registered keeper of the vehicle but was not the driver on the material date. The driver has never been identified.

2. The Particulars of Claim (PoC) are inadequately pleaded and fail to comply with CPR 16.4 and Practice Direction 16. The Claimant alleges a contract "agreed upon entry/parking" and identifies only the purported term "Permit Holders Only", but fails to plead the material contractual terms, the conduct said to constitute acceptance, the precise conduct constituting breach, the basis upon which the Defendant as keeper is said to be liable, or the contractual and legal basis for the £170 principal sum.

3. Where a claim is based upon an agreement by conduct, PD16 paragraph 7.5 requires the PoC to specify the conduct relied upon and state by whom, when and where the acts constituting that conduct were done. In Liberty Homes (Kent) Ltd v Rajakanthan & Ors [2022] EWHC 2201 (TCC), the High Court confirmed that a claimant must plead how the alleged contract was formed and the facts necessary to enable the defendant and the court to understand the contractual case advanced. The purpose of proper pleading was likewise explained in Towler v Wills [2010] EWHC 1209 (Comm). The present PoC do not satisfy those requirements.

4. The Defendant therefore invites the Court to strike out the claim pursuant to CPR 3.4(2)(a), or alternatively to require the Claimant properly to particularise its case.

5. No admission is made that any contract existed between the Claimant and the driver. If the material signage merely stated "Permit Holders Only", as pleaded, such wording is on its face prohibitory rather than an offer of parking to a person without a permit. The Claimant is put to strict proof of the complete signage in place on 1 May 2026, its location, prominence and wording, and how any contractual offer was communicated and accepted.

6. The Claimant is also put to strict proof of its standing and sufficient landholder authority at the material time to offer parking contracts, issue parking charges and pursue those charges by litigation in its own name.

7. The Claimant seeks to hold the Defendant liable as registered keeper under Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA). Strict compliance with the statutory conditions is required before liability can be transferred from an unidentified driver to a keeper.

8. The Notice to Keeper (NtK) fails to comply with PoFA paragraph 9(2)(a), which requires the notice to specify the "period of parking" to which it relates. The NtK merely states "From" and "To" timestamps derived from ANPR images recording the vehicle entering and leaving the site. Entry and exit timestamps are not a period of parking.

9. The distinction is material. In pre-action correspondence the Claimant expressly confirmed that its ANPR cameras record vehicles entering and exiting the car park and are not designed to monitor movements within it. The images therefore do not establish where the vehicle was parked, when any parking commenced or ended, whether the vehicle was parked throughout the interval, whether any permit condition was breached, or what signage applied at any alleged parked location.

10. Accordingly, the statutory condition in PoFA paragraph 9(2)(a) has not been satisfied and the Claimant cannot transfer the driver's alleged liability to this Defendant. There is no presumption in law that the registered keeper was the driver.

11. Further and in any event, PoFA paragraph 4(5) provides that the maximum sum recoverable from a keeper by virtue of Schedule 4 is the amount specified in the NtK. That amount was £100. The PoC nevertheless plead a principal debt of £170 before interest. No adequate contractual or legal basis for that additional £70 is pleaded.

12. The additional £70 is particularly objectionable because, before proceedings were commenced, the Claimant's own Legal Team expressly admitted that the Defendant's appeal of 15 May 2026 had been made within the appeal period and expressly stated: "The debt recovery fees and the Letter Before Action are withdrawn." The subsequent pleading of £170 therefore reinstates in this claim an additional sum which the Claimant had expressly withdrawn.

13. The Claimant's pre-action conduct is also relied upon. The Defendant submitted a formal complaint on 15 May 2026 challenging the validity of the PCN and therefore also constituting an appeal pursuant to clause 11.2 of the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice (PPSSCoP). The Claimant subsequently admitted that the appeal was timely and had been passed to its Appeals Team.

14. Notwithstanding that admission, the Claimant failed properly to conclude the appeal. It asserted that the appeal was "too late", escalated the charge, commenced debt recovery and issued a Letter Before Action before its Legal Team withdrew those steps. When subsequently maintaining that the PCN was correctly issued, the Claimant still failed to provide the POPLA verification code required to permit an independent appeal. The Defendant will rely upon the applicable provisions of the PPSSCoP, including clauses 8.4.6 and 11.2, and the complete correspondence trail.

15. The Claimant is put to strict proof of the alleged breach, including evidence of the vehicle's actual parked location, the material signage applicable to that location, the alleged absence of any required permit, the contractual terms relied upon, and the evidential basis upon which entry and exit ANPR images establish the pleaded breach "Permit Holders Only".

16. The Defendant denies the principal sum of £170 and consequently denies the claimed interest. The Defendant respectfully submits that the claim should be dismissed. The Defendant reserves the right to seek the costs permitted by CPR 27.14, including further costs pursuant to CPR 27.14(2)(g) should the Claimant's unreasonable conduct continue.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain


Messages In This Thread
RE: PCN Civil Enforcement Spring Hall Medical Practice, Halifax - by b789 - 11-17-2026, 07:18 PM

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Debt Recovery Plus APCOA Broad Street, Halifax samh47 5 594 10-28-2026, 09:50 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN APCOA Broad Street Plaza, Halifax 3Sh3roo 4 1,008 07-29-2026, 05:00 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN Broadway Retail Park, Halifax 3Sh3roo 2 700 07-14-2026, 11:02 PM
Last Post: 3Sh3roo
  Help needed with Civil Enforcement Ltd CCJ claim Arbitration 8 2,641 06-13-2026, 03:07 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN Excel Crossley Retail Park, Halifax 3Sh3roo 19 6,503 04-02-2026, 06:55 PM
Last Post: b789
  Re: PCN from 'Civil Enforcement Ltd' badrav 13 5,616 02-19-2026, 12:14 PM
Last Post: badrav
Information ParkingEye, Harrow Hall, Langley b789 1 1,137 01-24-2026, 10:24 AM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)