11-18-2026, 07:05 PM
@Benarty2016, before advising you on how to proceed, we need to establish two important points.
Firstly, as this is a leased vehicle, did Civil Enforcement Ltd (CEL) send you a Notice to Hirer (NtH)? If so, did it include copies of the hire agreement, the statement of liability signed by the hirer and the original Notice to Keeper sent to the leasing company? Please show us the notice you received, with your personal details redacted.
Under Schedule 4, paragraphs 13 and 14 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA), CEL must comply with specific requirements, including supplying the prescribed documents, before it can transfer liability from the unknown driver to the hirer. Failure to comply means CEL cannot hold you liable as the hirer.
Secondly, please reproduce exactly what you wrote to CEL in your letter, particularly any references to who was driving. Did you refer to the driver in the first person, using expressions such as "I parked" or "when I visited", or did you refer to "the driver" in the third person?
This distinction is extremely important. There is no legal obligation to identify the driver to a private parking company. If CEL knows who was driving, it can pursue that person directly without relying on PoFA. However, if the driver's identity remains unknown, CEL must establish liability through strict compliance with PoFA.
CEL, like virtually every other private parking operator, consistently fails to comply with PoFA's requirements for hire and lease vehicles. These are usually straightforward cases to defeat, provided the driver's identity has not been disclosed. Identifying the driver, even inadvertently, can throw away what would otherwise be a complete defence against hirer liability.
You can safely ignore the debt recovery letters. These powerless debt collectors have absolutely no authority to enforce payment, seize goods or affect your credit record. Their entire business model relies on sending increasingly threatening letters, hoping to frighten the low-hanging fruit on the gullible tree into paying out of ignorance and fear. No matter how intimidating these letters appear, they cannot damage your credit record. That would require a court judgment against you, followed by your failure to pay the judgment in full within one calendar month. Debt collectors have no such powers.
Finally, sending letters by registered or signed-for post is a pointless and unnecessary expense. All you need is a free Certificate of Posting from any Post Office, which provides evidence that the letter was posted. Signed-for delivery is particularly unhelpful because a recipient can simply refuse to sign for or accept the letter. All the tracking might then establish is that delivery was unsuccessful.
Once we have seen the NtH and your original letter, we can establish whether CEL has any lawful basis for pursuing you as the hirer.
Firstly, as this is a leased vehicle, did Civil Enforcement Ltd (CEL) send you a Notice to Hirer (NtH)? If so, did it include copies of the hire agreement, the statement of liability signed by the hirer and the original Notice to Keeper sent to the leasing company? Please show us the notice you received, with your personal details redacted.
Under Schedule 4, paragraphs 13 and 14 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA), CEL must comply with specific requirements, including supplying the prescribed documents, before it can transfer liability from the unknown driver to the hirer. Failure to comply means CEL cannot hold you liable as the hirer.
Secondly, please reproduce exactly what you wrote to CEL in your letter, particularly any references to who was driving. Did you refer to the driver in the first person, using expressions such as "I parked" or "when I visited", or did you refer to "the driver" in the third person?
This distinction is extremely important. There is no legal obligation to identify the driver to a private parking company. If CEL knows who was driving, it can pursue that person directly without relying on PoFA. However, if the driver's identity remains unknown, CEL must establish liability through strict compliance with PoFA.
CEL, like virtually every other private parking operator, consistently fails to comply with PoFA's requirements for hire and lease vehicles. These are usually straightforward cases to defeat, provided the driver's identity has not been disclosed. Identifying the driver, even inadvertently, can throw away what would otherwise be a complete defence against hirer liability.
You can safely ignore the debt recovery letters. These powerless debt collectors have absolutely no authority to enforce payment, seize goods or affect your credit record. Their entire business model relies on sending increasingly threatening letters, hoping to frighten the low-hanging fruit on the gullible tree into paying out of ignorance and fear. No matter how intimidating these letters appear, they cannot damage your credit record. That would require a court judgment against you, followed by your failure to pay the judgment in full within one calendar month. Debt collectors have no such powers.
Finally, sending letters by registered or signed-for post is a pointless and unnecessary expense. All you need is a free Certificate of Posting from any Post Office, which provides evidence that the letter was posted. Signed-for delivery is particularly unhelpful because a recipient can simply refuse to sign for or accept the letter. All the tracking might then establish is that delivery was unsuccessful.
Once we have seen the NtH and your original letter, we can establish whether CEL has any lawful basis for pursuing you as the hirer.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain

