10 hours ago
@onFourWheels, that decision is an absolute embarrassment. Please tell me the name of the assessor shown on the decision. Their name is in the public domain and, considering the quality of what they have produced here, I see no reason why they should be shielded from criticism.
The treatment of PoFA 9(2)(f) is breathtakingly incompetent. Premier Park's NtK expressly says that it may recover the unpaid charge "from the driver of the vehicle". Paragraph 9(2)(f) requires the mandatory warning that, subject to the statutory conditions, the unpaid charge may be recovered from the keeper. The assessor has somehow managed to read "driver" and conclude that it means "keeper". That is not interpretation. It is not even a difficult point of statutory construction. It is simply rewriting Premier Park's defective NtK for them because the actual wording does not establish keeper liability.
The paragraph 9(2)(a) reasoning is equally pathetic. PoFA requires a period of parking to be specified. The assessor says they are satisfied that "the period of parking is the period before 13:00". What period? Five seconds? Five minutes? Twenty minutes? An hour? There is no start time, no end time and no defined duration. Even more absurdly, the assessor expressly acknowledges that Premier Park's photographic evidence is timestamped at 12:40 but apparently sees nothing wrong with 13:00 being plucked out of thin air and then used as the reference point for some completely undefined "period" before it. That is precisely the issue they were required to determine, and they have simply waved it away.
The signage finding is scarcely any better. The Code requires that, for accessible parking, at least one sign containing the relevant terms and conditions must be capable of being viewed by the disabled driver without needing to leave the vehicle. The assessor instead decides that the sign was merely "visible from the disabled bay". Those are not the same test. A sign can plainly be visible without the contractual terms being readable from inside the vehicle.
Then we get to the landowner-authority section, which descends into farce. Rather than determine whether the Authority Agreement actually satisfies the specific requirements of the Code, the assessor speculates that if Premier Park no longer had authority, "it is likely that the landowner would remove the signage". That is not evidence. It is guesswork. Apparently we have reached the stage where contractual standing can be established by an assessor imagining what a landowner would probably do.
This is exactly why some POPLA decisions deserve outright ridicule. These assessors are being entrusted to determine questions involving statutory liability, contractual formation and evidential burdens, yet some appear incapable of applying even the plain wording of the legislation in front of them. When an assessor can look at the word "driver" and announce that it establishes liability against the keeper, it is difficult to regard the exercise as anything other than hopelessly incompetent. Decisions like this are also why people understandably start wondering whether some assessors are simply determined to find for the operator regardless of what the evidence or statute actually says.
I would not waste any meaningful effort complaining to POPLA. Experience shows that even when they accept that an assessor has got something wrong, it does not result in the decision being reversed. There is little point expending time trying to educate an organisation that appears perfectly content to allow reasoning of this standard to stand.
More importantly, the POPLA decision is not binding on you.
Premier Park can wave it around as much as they like, but it does not create a debt, it does not create keeper liability and it certainly does not bind a County Court judge. If Premier Park ultimately wants to recover the money, it will have to prove its case properly.
What happens next is entirely predictable. You will probably receive the usual succession of increasingly hysterical debt-recovery letters from whichever powerless debt collector Premier Park chooses to employ. They are worth precisely what they cost to print. Feel free to use them to line the bottom of a cat litter tray or as kindling; either use is considerably more productive than responding to them.
The next document that matters is a proper Letter of Claim. If/when one arrives, come back here. Until then, ignore the noise.
And if Premier Park are eventually foolish enough to issue a County Court claim, we can put the actual wording of Schedule 4 in front of a judge and see whether Premier Park wants to argue with a straight face that Parliament wrote "keeper", their NtK says "driver", but somehow both words mean the same thing because a POPLA assessor said so.
The treatment of PoFA 9(2)(f) is breathtakingly incompetent. Premier Park's NtK expressly says that it may recover the unpaid charge "from the driver of the vehicle". Paragraph 9(2)(f) requires the mandatory warning that, subject to the statutory conditions, the unpaid charge may be recovered from the keeper. The assessor has somehow managed to read "driver" and conclude that it means "keeper". That is not interpretation. It is not even a difficult point of statutory construction. It is simply rewriting Premier Park's defective NtK for them because the actual wording does not establish keeper liability.
The paragraph 9(2)(a) reasoning is equally pathetic. PoFA requires a period of parking to be specified. The assessor says they are satisfied that "the period of parking is the period before 13:00". What period? Five seconds? Five minutes? Twenty minutes? An hour? There is no start time, no end time and no defined duration. Even more absurdly, the assessor expressly acknowledges that Premier Park's photographic evidence is timestamped at 12:40 but apparently sees nothing wrong with 13:00 being plucked out of thin air and then used as the reference point for some completely undefined "period" before it. That is precisely the issue they were required to determine, and they have simply waved it away.
The signage finding is scarcely any better. The Code requires that, for accessible parking, at least one sign containing the relevant terms and conditions must be capable of being viewed by the disabled driver without needing to leave the vehicle. The assessor instead decides that the sign was merely "visible from the disabled bay". Those are not the same test. A sign can plainly be visible without the contractual terms being readable from inside the vehicle.
Then we get to the landowner-authority section, which descends into farce. Rather than determine whether the Authority Agreement actually satisfies the specific requirements of the Code, the assessor speculates that if Premier Park no longer had authority, "it is likely that the landowner would remove the signage". That is not evidence. It is guesswork. Apparently we have reached the stage where contractual standing can be established by an assessor imagining what a landowner would probably do.
This is exactly why some POPLA decisions deserve outright ridicule. These assessors are being entrusted to determine questions involving statutory liability, contractual formation and evidential burdens, yet some appear incapable of applying even the plain wording of the legislation in front of them. When an assessor can look at the word "driver" and announce that it establishes liability against the keeper, it is difficult to regard the exercise as anything other than hopelessly incompetent. Decisions like this are also why people understandably start wondering whether some assessors are simply determined to find for the operator regardless of what the evidence or statute actually says.
I would not waste any meaningful effort complaining to POPLA. Experience shows that even when they accept that an assessor has got something wrong, it does not result in the decision being reversed. There is little point expending time trying to educate an organisation that appears perfectly content to allow reasoning of this standard to stand.
More importantly, the POPLA decision is not binding on you.
Premier Park can wave it around as much as they like, but it does not create a debt, it does not create keeper liability and it certainly does not bind a County Court judge. If Premier Park ultimately wants to recover the money, it will have to prove its case properly.
What happens next is entirely predictable. You will probably receive the usual succession of increasingly hysterical debt-recovery letters from whichever powerless debt collector Premier Park chooses to employ. They are worth precisely what they cost to print. Feel free to use them to line the bottom of a cat litter tray or as kindling; either use is considerably more productive than responding to them.
The next document that matters is a proper Letter of Claim. If/when one arrives, come back here. Until then, ignore the noise.
And if Premier Park are eventually foolish enough to issue a County Court claim, we can put the actual wording of Schedule 4 in front of a judge and see whether Premier Park wants to argue with a straight face that Parliament wrote "keeper", their NtK says "driver", but somehow both words mean the same thing because a POPLA assessor said so.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain

