Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
PCN Civil Enforcement Spring Hall Medical Practice, Halifax
#31
Thanks for this, I am happy to file the defence now, please note it is for the registered keeper (I am their spouse). Really surprised it's got to this stage especially considering they admitted the LBA was a mistake and have not rejected the appeal nor issued a POPLA opportunity?! 

Can you please advise where I can file this online or do I need to fill the forms in? Do I need to wait until 30th Nov or just file it now as I don't need an AoS.
#32
@3Sh3roo, yes, you can file the Defence now. There is absolutely no need to wait until 30 November.

Because you are ready to submit the Defence, there is also no need to file an Acknowledgment of Service first. The purpose of the AoS in this situation would simply be to extend the Defence deadline from 14 days after service to 28 days after service. If you are happy with the Defence as drafted, you can go straight to filing it.

One important point from what you have just said: the registered keeper is your spouse and is the named Defendant. Therefore the Defence must be filed in their name, not yours. You can obviously assist them in preparing and submitting it, but it is their Defence and they must personally confirm the statement of truth.

Use the online response details supplied with the N1SDT Claim Form. Log into Money Claim Online (MCOL) using the claim number and the relevant login/security details on the claim paperwork. Select the option to defend the whole claim, and copy and paste the Defence into the Defence box.

Do not complete and send the paper Defence form as well. If the Defence is submitted online, that is the Defence filed with the court.

Before pressing the final submit button:

• check that the whole Defence has copied into the box and nothing has been truncated;
• make sure you are defending the whole claim;
• do not add a counterclaim;
• the registered keeper/Defendant must confirm the statement of truth; and
• after submission, save or screenshot the confirmation showing that the Defence has been received.

I share your surprise that CEL have allowed this to reach a claim. Their own Legal Team admitted that the original appeal was made in time, withdrew the debt-recovery fees and withdrew the previous Letter Before Action. They then failed to provide a POPLA opportunity and have nevertheless issued proceedings claiming £170, which appears to reinstate the very £70 that their Legal Team expressly said had been withdrawn.

All of that is preserved in the Defence as hooks for the later Witness Statement, when we can exhibit the correspondence and put the complete chronology before the judge.

I would still advise against a counterclaim. Their conduct may ultimately support an application for costs for unreasonable behaviour under CPR 27.14(2)(g), but that is different from having a separate cause of action entitling the Defendant to damages. There is no need to complicate this Defence with a speculative counterclaim.

If the court ultimately considers CEL's conduct unreasonable, we can seek the appropriate additional costs without having made a counterclaim.

So, if your spouse is happy with the Defence as drafted, file it now through MCOL and keep the submission confirmation.

You can file the Defence online through Money Claim Online (MCOL). The easiest way is as follows.

Quote:Go to the official MCOL page:

https://www.moneyclaim.gov.uk/web/mcol/welcome

Click "Login or Register".

You will then be taken through the Government Gateway sign-in. If you already have a Government Gateway user ID and password, use those. If you do not, you can create sign-in details there.

Once you are logged into MCOL, look for "Respond to a Claim made against you."

You will need:

• the Claim Number from the N1SDT Claim Form; and
• the Defence Pack Password shown on the claim paperwork. (In the "Important Note" section lower right of the N1SDT Form)

Enter those details to link the claim to your MCOL account.

Then select "Respond to Claim" and choose the option to defend the whole claim.

Because you are ready to file the Defence now, you do not need to submit an Acknowledgment of Service first. You can go straight to the Defence section and copy and paste the Defence I have drafted into the Defence box.

Before you submit it, check very carefully that:

• the entire Defence has copied across and nothing has been cut off;
• you are defending all of the claim;
• you are not making a counterclaim;
• the Defence is submitted in the name of the registered keeper, who is the named Defendant; and
• the Defendant personally confirms the Statement of Truth.

Once it has been submitted, take a screenshot or save the confirmation page so that you have proof that the Defence was filed.

Do not also send the paper Defence form if you have submitted the Defence online through MCOL.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#33
Thanks so much for this, one further complexity is that we've moved address since this issue (though we've still got access to the old property regularly, in fact this letter was sent there). Should I keep the old address or add the new one during individual enrolment? Will it complicate matters?
#34
@3Sh3roo, Yes — this is important, and you should not continue using the old address simply because you still have access to the property.

For this court claim, use the current address for the Defendant when dealing with MCOL. Because proceedings have already been issued, you should also notify both the court and CEL in writing that the Defendant's address for service has changed. Do not rely merely on changing the address within an online account.

More importantly, you now need to send a Data Rectification Notice (DRN) to the Data Protection Officer (DPO) of every private parking company with which either of you has any outstanding PCN.

This is extremely important. You can get the DPO email details in the privacy statement/notice on the firms website.

When a parking company obtains keeper details from the DVLA, it creates its own record containing the address supplied at that time. Moving house, changing the V5C or updating other records does not magically update the copy of your address already sitting on the parking company's system. They are only allowed to request the Keeper details from the DVLA once per PCN.

That creates the obvious danger that months or even years later they send a Letter of Claim or County Court claim to the old address. If you do not see it and do not respond, they can obtain a default judgment and you can end up discovering a CCJ only after the event.

Having occasional access to the old property is not an adequate safeguard.

A DRN puts the operator formally on notice that its existing address is no longer the Defendant's current address and requires it to rectify its records. The old address can remain recorded historically if necessary, but it must not continue to be treated as the current correspondence or service address.

When you send a DRN, make sure it identifies the actual parking records concerned.

A generic "I have moved house" email is not enough. The operator needs to be able to match the rectification request to the correct PCN records.

For each parking company, send one DRN listing every outstanding PCN reference they hold for you. If any matter has already reached court proceedings, also include the County Court claim number.

Use something along these lines:

Quote:Subject: Data Rectification Notice – PCN(s) [insert references] / Claim No. [if applicable]

Dear Data Protection Officer,

I require rectification of my personal data under Article 16 UK GDPR.

The following parking charge records are affected:

PCN: [reference] 
PCN: [reference] 
PCN: [reference]

Where applicable:

County Court Claim No: [claim number]

My previous address was:

[OLD ADDRESS]

My current address for all correspondence and service is:

[NEW ADDRESS]

Please rectify all records associated with the above PCN(s) and/or claim so that the new address is recorded as my current address for correspondence and service.

The previous address may remain on your records as historical information where necessary, but it must not be used as my current address for correspondence or service.

This rectification must also be applied to any associated debt recovery, legal, litigation or enforcement records.

Where you have disclosed my personal data to any third party in relation to the above PCN(s) or claim, please notify those recipients of the corrected address.

Please confirm when this rectification has been completed.

Yours faithfully,

[NAME]
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#35
Thanks once again, sorry to question this, the old address is now owned by a close family member and all letters are always passed on as we live within a couple of miles of each other, in fact it will remain within the family. There are no other PCN's on record (as least so far!).
#36
I understand why you feel reasonably safe leaving the old address in place if it is now owned by close family and all post is passed on. The problem is that, from a legal and credit-record perspective, that is still an unnecessary risk.

The important issue is not whether you are likely to receive the post. It is whether the parking company, its solicitors and the court hold the correct current address for service.

If a claim or other court document is sent to the old address and for any reason it is missed, delayed, mislaid or not passed on in time, the consequences can be serious. A parking company could obtain judgment in default simply because no response was filed by the deadline. Once a CCJ exists, the position becomes much more difficult and expensive to unwind. You may then have to make a formal set-aside application, pay the court fee, prepare evidence explaining why the claim was not received properly, and persuade a judge to set the judgment aside before you can even get back to defending the underlying parking charge.

That is a completely different problem from defending a £100 parking charge in the ordinary way.

There is also the practical issue for your family member. Even though a CCJ is registered against a person rather than against the property itself, having court correspondence, enforcement letters or tracing activity repeatedly associated with their address is something I would avoid entirely. It can create confusion, unwanted correspondence and, in the worst case, enforcement agents turning up at an address occupied by someone who has nothing to do with the debt.

So the fact that the old property remains in the family is actually a reason to make sure the records are corrected, not a reason to leave them as they are.

For this CEL case, because court proceedings are already live, I would make sure the court and CEL both have the correct current address immediately. And if there are no other outstanding PCNs, then there is no wider exercise to do at present.

It is a very small administrative step now that avoids a potentially much larger problem later.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#37
Thank you for this and for the clarity, I'll email Civil Enforcement DPO, do I need to email the court as well, can't seem to find any details for them.

Also, I've filed the defence, checked everything in full, ensured it was from my spouse, changed address to current one, taken image of the submitted page for my records and downloaded the submitted pdf doc.

Not sure what happens next, any dates I need to make a note of and any other details?

One final point, thank you so much for preparing the defence, their website returned one error, it did not allow the " characters, I changed them to ' and it was fine to proceed to the next page.
#38
@3Sh3roo, that all sounds exactly right. You have filed the Defence in the Defendant's name, used the current address, checked the complete text before submission and retained both a screenshot and the downloaded PDF. Keep those safely.

Changing the double quotation marks `"` to single quotation marks `'` is completely immaterial. That is simply an MCOL character restriction and does not alter the Defence in any substantive way.

Address change

Yes, I would also notify the court directly of the new address, even though you entered the new address when filing the Defence. There is no benefit in leaving any room for doubt over the Defendant's address for service.

The Civil National Business Centre specifically gives the following email address for address changes:

CaseProgression.CNBC@justice.gov.uk

Send a very short email from the Defendant along these lines:

Quote:Subject: Claim No. [CLAIM NUMBER] – Defendant's change of address

Dear Sir/Madam,

I am the Defendant in the above claim.

Please update the court record to show that my current address for service is:

[NEW ADDRESS]

My previous address, shown on the Claim Form, was:

[OLD ADDRESS]

I have also provided my current address when filing my Defence through MCOL.

Please confirm that the court record has been updated accordingly.

Yours faithfully,

[DEFENDANT'S FULL NAME]

I would also send the Data Rectification Notice to CEL's DPO, quoting both PCN 1895******** and the County Court claim number, and copy legal@ce-service.co.uk because proceedings are now live.

What happens next?

For the moment, you do nothing further. There is no immediate deadline for you now that the Defence has been filed.

The court will provide CEL with the Defence. CEL then has to decide whether it wishes to continue with the claim. Under the MCOL procedure, if the Claimant does not send the necessary instructions to the court within 33 days after the Defence, the claim will normally be stayed. You do not need to do anything to make that happen.

If CEL decides to continue — which we should assume it will unless told otherwise — the next document you should expect is normally a Notice of Proposed Allocation to the Small Claims Track, together with a Directions Questionnaire (N180).

When that arrives, do not ignore it. It will contain a specific deadline. We can deal with the N180 when you receive it. A completed Directions Questionnaire has to be filed with the court and a copy served on CEL.

After the Directions Questionnaires have been dealt with, the case will ordinarily be transferred to the local County Court hearing centre for the Defendant. Eventually there will be a Notice of Allocation containing the hearing arrangements and, importantly, the deadline for exchanging Witness Statements and evidence.

That later Witness Statement stage is where we put the flesh onto the hooks already pleaded in the Defence. That will include CEL's own correspondence admitting that:

• your original appeal was received in time;
• they wrongly told you it was too late;
• they escalated it to debt recovery while the appeal remained unresolved;
• their Legal Team expressly withdrew the debt-recovery fees and Letter Before Action;
• they never provided the promised POPLA opportunity; and
• despite withdrawing the debt-recovery fees, their subsequent court claim nevertheless pleads £170 as the principal debt.

For now, there are therefore only three things to do:

1. email the CNBC confirming the new address;
2. send the DRN to CEL's DPO, quoting the PCN and claim number; and
3. keep watching the post, email and MCOL for the next court communication.

There is no need to contact CEL about the merits of the claim anymore. They have chosen litigation, so the Defence has now answered them.

Also keep every document, email and envelope relating to this matter. Assuming CEL continues, we will need them for the Witness Statement and potentially for a later application for costs under CPR 27.14(2)(g) if the court considers CEL's conduct unreasonable.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#39
Thank you for this, in all honesty it does seem quite daunting that it has come so far, especially considering how they've screwed this up, further I learnt today that the specific medical center has scrapped this parking policy so no more 'fines'!

Is there a risk they will take this further? What can they hope to achieve?
#40
@3Sh3roo, yes, there is a real possibility CEL will take this all the way to a hearing. In fact, I would proceed on the assumption that they probably will.

That should not be confused with them having a strong case.

From what I have seen, CEL's legal department is utterly inept. Their litigation appears to operate on a conveyor-belt basis, with little evidence of competent legal scrutiny before claims are issued or pursued. They seem perfectly capable of ignoring glaring defects in their own case, contradicting their own previous correspondence and pressing ahead regardless. That is exactly what they have done here.

I am currently dealing with another CEL matter which illustrates this rather spectacularly. In that case, CEL previously lost on summary judgment and ended up paying the defendant over £1,000. Despite that, they later issued a further batch of 7 claims arising from essentially the same underlying ANPR problem. Those claims are now facing further applications which put CEL in a very difficult position indeed.

That tells you a lot about the quality of legal decision-making going on there. A competent legal department would normally recognise when its own evidence, procedural history or previous losses make further litigation commercially or legally foolish. CEL's appears quite capable of doing the opposite.

So yes, they may well continue. What are they hoping to achieve? Ultimately, payment. They will be hoping that the court process itself persuades you to give up and pay, or that they eventually obtain judgment for whatever sums a judge permits. Parking companies also benefit enormously when defendants fail to engage and allow default judgments to be entered. You are not doing that.

Your case has several particularly awkward features for CEL. They admitted that your original appeal was lodged in time after previously claiming otherwise; withdrew the debt-recovery fees and Letter Before Action; never provided the promised POPLA opportunity; and then issued proceedings claiming £170, apparently reinstating the very debt-recovery amount their own Legal Team had already withdrawn.

There is also the separate PoFA issue concerning the absence of any actual period of parking and their own admission that the ANPR system only records entry and exit.

The fact that the medical centre has now abandoned this particular parking regime is interesting context, although it does not automatically cancel an historic PCN. Keep any evidence you can obtain confirming that the policy has been scrapped, because depending on why it was removed it may become useful later.

So yes, CEL may well carry on. Do not interpret that as evidence that they have suddenly discovered a strong case. It is just as likely to be evidence that their legal department is continuing to do what it appears to do best: plough ahead first and think about the legal weaknesses later.

You have filed a proper Defence. If they continue to a hearing, we deal with the Witness Statement and evidence when the court orders that stage. If they continue behaving unreasonably, their conduct can also be put before the judge when costs are considered.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Debt Recovery Plus APCOA Broad Street, Halifax samh47 5 585 10-28-2026, 09:50 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN APCOA Broad Street Plaza, Halifax 3Sh3roo 4 1,002 07-29-2026, 05:00 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN Broadway Retail Park, Halifax 3Sh3roo 2 695 07-14-2026, 11:02 PM
Last Post: 3Sh3roo
  Help needed with Civil Enforcement Ltd CCJ claim Arbitration 8 2,630 06-13-2026, 03:07 PM
Last Post: b789
  PCN Excel Crossley Retail Park, Halifax 3Sh3roo 19 6,479 04-02-2026, 06:55 PM
Last Post: b789
  Re: PCN from 'Civil Enforcement Ltd' badrav 13 5,603 02-19-2026, 12:14 PM
Last Post: badrav
Information ParkingEye, Harrow Hall, Langley b789 1 1,134 01-24-2026, 10:24 AM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)